Where Does Brett Favre Rank......

[mavskidd02]

I knew he would rank Favre ahead of Brady but his reasons leave me stunned .......

Those numbers are GREAT by Favre. Are you kidding me???

What/

I didn't rank Favre ahead of Brady in anything but skill and leadership.

As to who I would want to win one game, one season, one something, I don't know, it depends on whether we are talking or now, or in their "prime"

[frankb03]

As for putting it on the line? No Brady doesn't nearly as well as Favre. Brady would never get fined for a crack back block. He would never sprint thirty yards up field and throw a cut block, nor would Manning. They are great QBs, they wouldn't sacrifice their bodies to the extent Favre has or is planned to.

Please!!! What about vs Steelers. Favre crumbled to the ground making a pussy attempt at knocking the defender out of bounds on the Pick-6. If Favre made the tackle ESPN would have rammed it down out throats.

The crack back block was bush league. The defender wasn't even looking. Brett dropped to his knees. You think he should be complimented for that?

[wayne1218]

What/

I didn't rank Favre ahead of Brady in anything but skill and leadership.

As to who I would want to win one game, one season, one something, I don't know, it depends on whether we are talking or now, or in their "prime"

A skill that includes the most interceptions in NFL History too? Was that skill included?

[mavskidd02]

You are OUT OF YOUR MIND Mavs .........

You let me know who you think is tougher. Favre or Brady.

All right then, I'm out of my mind....

You're nuts if you think Brady goes harder than Favre in a football game, there's just no chance.

[wayne1218]

You let me know who you think is tougher. Favre or Brady.

All right then, I'm out of my mind....

You're nuts if you think Brady goes harder than Favre in a football game, there's just no chance.

Tougher? Who knows, this isn't the UFC mavs. I'm talking TOTAL package here.

[frankb03]

Leadership isn't just on the field mavs, it is on and off the field and i can't believe you would even think of disputing that.

IMO leadership off the field is as important as on the field.

[mavskidd02]

A skill that includes the most interceptions in NFL History too? Was that skill included?

Skill, terms of pure passing skill. Terms of go hit that target 50 yards downfield. I think Favre could do that better than Brady.

Does that make him a better QB? No. Decision making factors in too, something Brady is very good at, and Favre isn;t.

[mavskidd02]

Tougher? Who knows, this isn't the UFC mavs. I'm talking TOTAL package here.

Whole package in terms of what? Leading? Or being a QB?

Leading: Favre is better.

QB: Another story.

[wayne1218]

Skill, terms of pure passing skill. Terms of go hit that target 50 yards downfield. I think Favre could do that better than Brady.

I would take Brady 1 million times a day over favre. I've seen a zillion people on tv say nobody has a better motion and accuracy than Brady. You are simply out of your mind.

[mavskidd02]

Please!!! What about vs Steelers. Favre crumbled to the ground making a pussy attempt at knocking the defender out of bounds on the Pick-6. If Favre made the tackle ESPN would have rammed it down out throats.

The crack back block was bush league. The defender wasn't even looking. Brett dropped to his knees. You think he should be complimented for that?

QB's are expected to be excellent tacklers. The other 10 guys on the field, had no chance to make that tackle.

[frankb03]

As to who I would want to win one game, one season, one something, I don't know, it depends on whether we are talking or now, or in their "prime"

Again please! Outside of the 2 Superbowl runs when the Packers were 5-1 Favre's playoff record is terrible. One would think a QB as great as Favre is portrayed he would have gone deeper into the playoffs than just one conference championship is 12 years.

[frankb03]

QB's are expected to be excellent tacklers. The other 10 guys on the field, had no chance to make that tackle.

You're so called crack back stud crumbled to the ground. He didn't even attempt to make a play. You reward the guy for making an illegal bush league play. Yet make an excuse for him on his lack of attempt to prevent a pick6 in a critical situation.

[mavskidd02]

I would take Brady 1 million times a day over favre. I've seen a zillion people on tv say nobody has a better motion and accuracy than Brady. You are simply out of your mind.

That's your opinion and that's fine.

TV? I don't think anyone on TV would ever say anything bad about Favre or Brady, they are not allowed to.

Out of my mind? By your standards, yes. By my standards, I would call it biased.

[wayne1218]

mavs, Brady and his mechanics have been talked about for YEARS. Other HOF QB's have studied him and said he is flawless. Are you kidding? No, seriously, are you??

[molta02]

this thread is laughable.