Where Does Brett Favre Rank......

[frankb03]

As to who I would want to win one game, one season, one something, I don't know, it depends on whether we are talking or now, or in their "prime"

I read this before. I went back and read it again.

I interpreted this before and still do now as you insinuating that in each of their prime you'd take Favre.

[mavskidd02]

HE IS!!!!!!!!

Why do you think people have him rated so highly???????????

By your math, Favre sucks because he throws too many INT's right? That is what you said, isn't it?

So by your math, Favre is the greatest of all time, he's broken every meaningful passing record there is to break.

Wins, yards, TDs, completions. He has them all.

Does either make him the best or worst ever? Of course not, they are numbers in a book.

That is why I said, "settle" down with the INT garbage.

[mavskidd02]

I read this before. I went back and read it again.

I interpreted this before and still do now as you insinuating that in each of their prime you'd take Favre.

You interpreted "I don't know" as "I want Favre"

[wayne1218]

By your math, Favre sucks because he throws too many INT's right? That is what you said, isn't it?

So by your math, Favre is the greatest of all time, he's broken every meaningful passing record there is to break.

Wins, yards, TDs, completions. He has them all.

Does either make him the best or worst ever? Of course not, they are numbers in a book.

That is why I said, "settle" down with the INT garbage.

No mavs, that is WHY he is NOT higher on my list. If you count records, you need to count them all.

[mavskidd02]

No mavs, that is WHY he is NOT higher on my list. If you count records, you need to count them all.

You need to count them all too, he can't be bad because of INTs. It doesn't make any sense, because he holds ten more records on the + side to outweigh it.

1 out of every 33 passes is a pick. That ain't half bad at all.

[frankb03]

You interpreted "I don't know" as "I want Favre"

it depends on whether we are talking or now, or in their "prime"

I read it as you don't know who'd you take now. But in their "prime" you'd take Favre.

There's no wrong or right here. It's how I read this post.

[mavskidd02]

I read it as you don't know who'd you take now. But in their "prime" you'd take Favre.

There's no wrong or right here. It's how I read this post.

I know Frank, I could see how it came off.

With typing on the internet, people can't determine sarcasm from seriousness, or tone of voice.

That's what leads to half the stupid arguments here.

Are you done posting NBA this year? I look for your insight.

[frankb03]

Are you done posting NBA this year? I look for your insight.

No. I've been super busy at work this week. I did take a look today but didn't like anything.

[flarendep1]

That is such BS. Does Cal Ripken Jr hold the All time record for errors? No ........

I hope he buys the Orioles someday!!

[wayne1218]

You need to count them all too, he can't be bad because of INTs. It doesn't make any sense, because he holds ten more records on the + side to outweigh it.

1 out of every 33 passes is a pick. That ain't half bad at all.

I never ever said he was bad. If i thought he was bad, i wouldn't have him ranked around 10th all time. So in reality, it does make sense.

[musclemann]

this thread is laughable.

Rothleisburger is better than favre at the same point in their career. Who has been his all pro receivers in pittsburgh? Running backs?


And he has more rings than your alltime great.

[jordanrules23]

Rothleisburger is better than favre at the same point in their career. Who has been his all pro receivers in pittsburgh? Running backs?


And he has more rings than your alltime great.

now i know your smoking crack

[musclemann]

now i know your smoking crack

Once again you with a comment that is unwarrantied and out of line..............someone please take a look at these comments.

[PhilJr]

Rothleisburger is better than favre at the same point in their career. Who has been his all pro receivers in pittsburgh? Running backs?


And he has more rings than your alltime great.

Did anyone consider the defensive side? The Steelers have consistently ranked top 5 every year Big Ben has been there. Think that may help a little bit???

As my last employer told me, there is no I in team. I told him there was a U in Fuck You. That's when I found out there was an I in fired.

[harold_bush]

I am not a Favre guy, but I'm quite impressed with what he is still doing. Through 8 games he has 16 TDs and 3 interceptions this year. Remarkable. Last year through the whole 16 game season the Vikes has 21 TDs and 17 interceptions.