Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Where do you rank Mcnabb?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Where do you rank Mcnabb?

    For the sake of this thread put - Who else would you rather QB for the Eagles for this year-- I only have 3 others that I would put ahead of him. Peyton, Vick, Brady. Very close but I put Carson Palmer, Big Ben, Hasslebeck behind him.
    Consider everyone healthy

  • #2
    1-Brady
    2-P. Manning
    3-Palmer
    4-Big Ben
    5-Green
    6-Vick
    7-McNabb
    8-Hasslebeck
    5* 0-0
    4* 0-0
    3* 1-0
    2* 1-0
    1* 0-1


    God Bless America




    To win :1* unit = $100

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by cpickard43
      For the sake of this thread put - Who else would you rather QB for the Eagles for this year-- I only have 3 others that I would put ahead of him. Peyton, Vick, Brady. Very close but I put Carson Palmer, Big Ben, Hasslebeck behind him.
      Consider everyone healthy

      lol, Vick? He is the most overrated PLAYER in the NFL.

      Comment


      • #4
        cmon palmer and green before mcnabb no way...cinncy aint beat anybody good this year, got spanked today....green has running game w/ holmes/johnson and decent receivers mcnabb plays banged up and still wins in the past he has won games basically on his own mcnabb is not overatted at all sure maybe not as good as peyton, brady but hes right there for 3 w/ vick
        edification will take place pull up the reins and get outta the race.

        Comment


        • #5
          I think Brady and Manning are better than McNabb...I think palmer is close, but let's see if he can keep it up for a whole season

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by cpickard43
            For the sake of this thread put - Who else would you rather QB for the Eagles for this year-- I only have 3 others that I would put ahead of him. Peyton, Vick, Brady. Very close but I put Carson Palmer, Big Ben, Hasslebeck behind him.
            Consider everyone healthy
            1- Brady 2 - Manning 3 - McNab 4 - Palmer 5 - Big Ben 6 - Bulger 7 - Favre 8 - Hassleback 9 - Vick 10 - Eli Manning

            * i do not think vick has done much....i keep hearing about it, but i am unconvinced and if i were starting a team he would not be my guy

            Comment


            • #7
              1. Manning
              2. Brady
              3. McNabb
              4. Marc Bulger
              5. BRETT FAVRE!!! (Packerskoach)
              6. T. Green
              7. Palmer

              Comment


              • #8
                There's no doubt I'd take Big Ben before I'd take McNabb. He finds a way to win.

                Comment


                • #9
                  In No particular order

                  Ben
                  Manning brothers
                  Brady
                  Palmer
                  Favre
                  Brees
                  Brunell

                  If you want to go with NFL QB rating. McNabb is #10

                  I know some will think I'm partial by going with Eli. Put Eli on the Eagles with their running game and defense and he'd get more respect as a QB. Eli has less than a full season under his belt as a NFL QB. Eli with his one dimensional offense is only 2 points behind McNabb in the QB rating. With his youth I'd take Eli before I take McNabb.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by SFLINSJ
                    lol, Vick? He is the most overrated PLAYER in the NFL.
                    I agree

                    Vick is a great running back that can throw the football.

                    Vick is a below average QB

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Frank you are crazy. Big Ben throws the ball only 15 times a game.
                      Carson Palmer has only had a few productive games in his career.
                      Maybe Brett Favre 5 years ago but now Favre suck. Favre throws more Int's in 1 season that Mcnabb throws in 2.
                      Drew Brees is only good beacuse of Having LT in the backfield. the Chargers even used a #1 pick on a QB last year.That shows how much faith they have in Brees.
                      Give me a break with Mark Brunell. Mark Brunell has always sucked. this year he is playing decnt but over Mcnabb you crazy.
                      Eli manning is still to early to tell. I think he is good but time will tell.
                      Also you said that Ben finds a way to win well how about McNabb the last 5 years 11,11,12,12,13. Give me a break McNabb is a great QB!
                      2010: 23-12 +37.8
                      2011: 4-0 + 20
                      09-11 5*s and up: 34-7

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by mark30
                        Frank you are crazy. Big Ben throws the ball only 15 times a game.
                        Carson Palmer has only had a few productive games in his career.
                        Maybe Brett Favre 5 years ago but now Favre suck. Favre throws more Int's in 1 season that Mcnabb throws in 2.
                        Drew Brees is only good beacuse of Having LT in the backfield. the Chargers even used a #1 pick on a QB last year.That shows how much faith they have in Brees.
                        Give me a break with Mark Brunell. Mark Brunell has always sucked. this year he is playing decnt but over Mcnabb you crazy.
                        Eli manning is still to early to tell. I think he is good but time will tell.
                        Also you said that Ben finds a way to win well how about McNabb the last 5 years 11,11,12,12,13. Give me a break McNabb is a great QB!
                        Mark,

                        You've raised some compelling arguements. Now my rebuttal.

                        I put Palmer with Eli. If I had to choose a QB to lead my team this year as well as in the future I'd take Palmer.

                        Favre sucks? He's playing with a very lousy team and an offensive line that gives him little protection. Put Favre on this Eagles team they would have won a Super Bowl or two and is probablly undefeated this season. At worse they have one loss.

                        Drew Brees is only good beacuse of Having LT in the backfield. I say the same with many good NFL QBs including Ben. McNabb has had the luxury of playing with a good running game and a great D for most of his career.

                        Brunell's career stats compare closely to McNabb's. Brunell didn't have the luxury of playing with a great team. He did a great job with a expansion team. Last season the greatest QB in the history of the NFL wouldn't win with the Skins. Once again IMO the Eagles are a better team if Brunell was their QB than with McNabb.

                        I understand your point with Ben. However, once again if I'm a team general manager and I had to choose between the two QBs I'd take Ben. In Ben's first year in the league his stats were comparable to McNabb's.
                        Last edited by frankb03; 10-24-2005, 10:41 AM.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Didn't Rush Limbaugh have some choice things to say about Mcnabb a year or so ago which weren't too kind and got him in trouble?

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by savage1
                            Didn't Rush Limbaugh have some choice things to say about Mcnabb a year or so ago which weren't too kind and got him in trouble?
                            IMO Limbaugh comments were blown out of proportion.

                            He said McNabb was overrated because the media wanted to see a black quarterback succeed. Is that racist? IMO NO

                            If Limbaugh had said McNabb sucks because he's black or McNabb is an overrated black QB those comments would be racist. But that's not what he said.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Good points also Frank.
                              The Palmer and Eli statements are true. Those 2 will be very good QB's in this league. But for now I would take McNabb. 2 or 3 years from now Palmer and Eli could very well be better than Donovan.
                              The thing with Favre is he is a turnover machine. Even when he had good teams he always threw INT's. Remember the play off game he had against the Rams when he threw 6. I don't think Donvan has many more than 6 six in all his playoff games.
                              2010: 23-12 +37.8
                              2011: 4-0 + 20
                              09-11 5*s and up: 34-7

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X