Where do you rank Mcnabb?

[mgdog96]

Most think Joey Harrington is a lousy QB. IMO if Joey QBed the Eagles the past few years the Eagles wouldn't have done any better or any worse.

Your kidding right?

[frankb03]

Your kidding right?

Actually I was. I was wondering how long it would take for someone to respond.

I was trying to make a point. I truly believe that the Eagles would have done better through the years with most NFL QBs other than McNabb.

[Kaptain]

Visualing other QB,s playing for the Eagles, which is the only fair way to do it.....I think the Eagles would have fared better if they had the following QB instead of McNabb...

Brady
P Manning
B Favre
Palmer

McNab can hold his own---is a good QB---but I think they would have fared better with the 4 listed QB's----playing on the same team McNabb had.....

[frankb03]

For the sake of this thread put - Who else would you rather QB for the Eagles for this year-- I only have 3 others that I would put ahead of him. Peyton, Vick, Brady. Very close but I put Carson Palmer, Big Ben, Hasslebeck behind him.
Consider everyone healthy

The original question was "Who would you rather QB for the Eagles for this year".

McNabb is

10th in QB rating
15th in Completion %
19th in Yards per Att.

McNabb is leading the league in pass attempts. Philly won't win in Nov, Dec and Jan if they are passing 40+ times per game.