Russ Limbaugh was Right :

[$$PIX]

Let's stop trying to narrow it down.....the guy just SUCKS!

I don't really care about the Eagles or who they replace McNabb with!

[jason]

McNabb is a baller and I would take him on my team anyday of the week. Carolina was just the better team. In the NFL anybody can win anyday. If Philly would have won everybody would probably say that Delhomme sucks!!!!!!!

[Shleprock]

Every qb sucks when their Team loses right,. Give me some reasons why Mcnabb sucks just because they lost the game is not very compelling. Do you think if Peyton Manning had the Eagles receivers he would have brought the team this far? Oh how could he,he has one of the best receivers and running backs and an excellent offensive line but throws 4 picks yesterday. Manning really sucks never ever has won a big game. Favre sucks to he threw a stupid interception last week. I nominate Brady for the hall of fame when they win the super bowl. Delhome sucks because they will lose.

[Stripe]

Doc

your showing your political registration (Dem). There is a bottom line for everything, and the bottom line for the running QB Donovan is that he is not a passing QB. The media DOES try and make him out to be what he is not, a PROFESSIONAL QB. There are dozens and dozens of QB in the college ranks like Donovan, and that is where QB like him should be, and not running a pro team. Remember Doc, the pros are BIG TIME, and pro teams need good defense, and a QB who can pass the ball to win the big one. Pro football is a long season, and at times running Donovan will look good, but in the end the score will still be Panthers 14 Eagles 3. As for Rush L., remember it's all entertainment in his line of work, and he is excellent at what he does, unlike running Donovan.

[wallstreet]

Looking at pure QB ratings, McNubb is not a great QB. You dont have to go any further than the numbers.

I part blame that on Reid and how he forced Donny into a plastic mold, his west coast offense..if you watched him years ago when he tried to do things by instinct and move in the pocket, he was so dangerous that teams had to take a player off the game and just watch him. Now the guy is no more mobile than Kurt Warner (kidding, but he is fat and much slower now)

If you think the receivers were poor, or the defense was bad to the run or that they were conservative, that all goes back to my thought. The reason for the loss is Reid..he made the personel decisions, called the plays, forced McNubb into being a quasi Brett Favre and he isnt that player.

Blame Reid and continue to blame Reid no matter who the QB is or what..he doesnt deserve the accolades, hell he doesnt deserve to be GM or coach. Let him be a QB coach..that is all he did prior to Philly.

Donny needs to lose some weight, lose the somber attitude and sack up. Reid needs to lose about 100 lbs and hand over a bunch of responsibility to others..especially GM.

Now behave and get along..

[Brandtcountry]

Someone Define Racist to me ?? I'm just an old hill jack from Ohio and wonderin if I might be one....By the way, I usually route for the slow white guy in every sporting event..only because he's the underdog..

[doc mercer]

Stripe:

What are you talking about?

I love sports and was totally insulted when ESPN hired
this frickin Idiot .... I stated facts and where did I bring up
politics? Limbaugh got out of the war - as did Dean, Bush
& Cheny - and his statements about McNabb had nothing
to do with the press ... The "King of Denny's Restaurant
Parking Lot Illegal Drug Pickups" is grossly Racist and used
that angle to show his true inner feelings

McNabb is not the best qb in the NFL ... he ain't the worse
and face facts: he is surrounded by an average corp of
wideouts and running backs .... put this guy on The Rams and
folks would view him in a different light

The guys that were praising Manning a week ago are now the
same idiots that were posting "Another Manning Choke" which I saw at numerous sites

[BettorsChat]

Brandtcountry,

Welcome to the forum

[coonsis]

RUSH WAS RIGHT!!!

RUSH WAS RIGHT. I MEAN ALL HE SAID WAS THAT MCNABB WAS OVERATED WHICH IS THE ABSOLUTE TRUTH!!! IF HE WAS A WHITE Q-BACK, HE WOULDN'T EVEN SNIF THE PRO BOWL. LOOK AT HIS ACCURACY. LETS JUST LOOK AT HISTORY. SCRAMBLING Q-B'S ALWAYS FALL SHORT TO THE POCKET ONES!! THIS YEAR BRADY VS DELHOMME, LAST YEAR BRAD JOHNSON BEAT A SCRAMBLING QB IN GANNON AND SO ON AND SO ON, WARNER OVER MCNAIR, MONTANA OVER ELWAY , BRADSHAW OVER STAUBACH, AND TARKENTON!!!!!

[MemphisMafia]

Pandoras Box :

What have I done ?

I simply stated he is not in this ladys estimation a Pro QB of any substance that I will acknowledge with my mental capacity . And to that end Russ was right , granted as said by wallstreet hes been pushed into this mold by Reid ( go back and read the first post ).

I now agree with wallstreet again , let it go fellas !

Lets all get along or I will turn the dogs loose on ya !

L O V E


G.L.

***MMM***

:cool: :cool: :cool:

[doc mercer]

I think we let McNabb play his entire career before tagging him
as Over-Rated ... that tag, along with Choker, is very unfair to
athletes - Male or Female - who give it 100% and come up short

Let's compare McNabb vs a QB who put up average numbers but
is considered one of the greats because he was QB on heavy
talent loaded Super Bowl Teams - Troy Aikman ... first 5 yrs:

The pt was Aikman was overhyped and his numbers were aveage @ best .... he was lucky he was surrounded with the talent he had - Luck of the draw as Dallas won the coin flip and GB took Tony Mandarich

Let's compare Aikman vs McNabb .. first 5 yrs:

Aikman 61.5% vs 56% for McNabb
Aikman 69 Tds vs 87 for McNabb
Aikman 66 Ints vs 49 for McNabb
Aikman with 709 Rush Yds vs 2242 for McNabb
Aikman with 5 rush tds vs 17 for McNabb
Aikman with 3 Pro Bowls vs 4 for McNabb

I respect McNabb for taking Philly as far as he has with average
talent to throw to year in and year out ....

[BettorsChat]

I personally never liked Aikman and think he was an average QB on a very talented team.