Since 1990 Who Would Your Top 5 College Football Players Everyone Join Will Be Good

[frankb03]

3 very quickly come to mind

1. Reggie Bush
2. Michael Vick
3. Tim Tebow

4. Calvin Johnson
5. Ricky Williams

[frankb03]

Same with Ricky Williams.I have seen him listed a couple times also.What a waste of talent for him and Vick.

I don't consider Vick a waste of talent at the NFL level. I never expected him to become an elite NFL QB.

[frankb03]

LT

LaDainian Tomlinson? I know he was the 5th pick of the draft in 2001. I also know he had great junior and senior years. I don't remember fans and the media saying he's one of the greatest college football players.

[Spearit]

3 very quickly come to mind

1. Reggie Bush
2. Michael Vick
3. Tim Tebow

4. Calvin Johnson
5. Ricky Williams

Nice to see ya frank.
Maybe its being here in Florida but if Tebow stays healthy - he be in the running again the next two years for the Heisman.
His missionary/christian background and setting goals remind me of Danny Wuerful.

[vols fan]

I don't consider Vick a waste of talent at the NFL level. I never expected him to become an elite NFL QB.

Elite he wasn't,exciting he was.He had alot of talent just not at the QB position.

[vols fan]

3 very quickly come to mind

1. Reggie Bush
2. Michael Vick
3. Tim Tebow

4. Calvin Johnson
5. Ricky Williams

Another one I liked watching,Calvin Johnson.Nice list Frank

[Spearit]

I Think I Missed One On My Top 5 List

Danny Wuerful Was There Any A Better Qb Than Him In College Football.i Think It Was 3 Sec Championships And 2 National Titles With Him As Qb Does Anyone Have The Info On Him But As A College Player He Was $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

Danny had Ike Hilliard and several other great receivers and that strong cast propelled him to the Heisman and National Championship and then NFL. Tebow has a few receivers but very green. It speaks volumns when a one player can dominate a game or games in a season. Tebow can. Danny was more of a system QB with excellent skills.

[garth]

Vince Young
Reggie Bush
Roy Williams
Adrian Peterson
Michael Vick

[wayne1218]

Thats a good point BUT the best college football coach(in my time) being at Florida at the same time didn't help Peyton either.It's hard to take away from Peyton when Phil Fulmer was the one losing the games to Florida.Spurrier out coached him every year.

I think Spurrier gets alot more credit than he deserved. Urban Meyer hasn't missed a beat there. It's about the players. If you get the best ones, any coach can look good. On the field, Peyton never made the plays against Florida when the game was on. He flat out choked against the Gators and couldn't make the plays in the 4th when he needed them. A National Champion OR Heisman Trophy Winner would have found a way to get it done. Look at what Vince Young did for Texas. He absolutely picked that whole team up on his own when they beat USC. He made Mack Brown go from a guy who couldn't win the big one to a National Champion. Peyton never beat the biggest opponent on his schedule (Florida) once and he can't be a top 5 player because of it.

[vols fan]

I think Spurrier gets alot more credit than he deserved. Urban Meyer hasn't missed a beat there. It's about the players. If you get the best ones, any coach can look good. On the field, Peyton never made the plays against Florida when the game was on. He flat out choked against the Gators and couldn't make the plays in the 4th when he needed them. A National Champion OR Heisman Trophy Winner would have found a way to get it done. Look at what Vince Young did for Texas. He absolutely picked that whole team up on his own when they beat USC. He made Mack Brown go from a guy who couldn't win the big one to a National Champion. Peyton never beat the biggest opponent on his schedule (Florida) once and he can't be a top 5 player because of it.

I looked at it as the Top 5 guys I enjoyed watching.He was one of them.You have your list and I have mine.I enjoyed watching him in college.

[wayne1218]

I looked at it as the Top 5 guys I enjoyed watching.He was one of them.You have your list and I have mine.I enjoyed watching him in college.

I guess there are biased and unbiased lists out there. I should have figured that by your avatar.

[vols fan]

I guess there are biased and unbiased lists out there. I should have figured that by your avatar.

And I should have figured you don't like Peyton by your avatar

[wayne1218]

And I should have figured you don't like Peyton by your avatar

Why does he play baseball???

I like Peyton alot actually. My name isn't dimer and i don't hate the guy at all. The facts are the facts buddy. How many Heisman's, National Titles and wins vs Florida combined did he have in College?

[vols fan]

I guess there are biased and unbiased lists out there. I should have figured that by your avatar.

I chose Peyton because I needed a white guy on my list
You want to see biased,go look at JC's picks.

[vols fan]

Why does he play baseball???

I like Peyton alot actually. My name isn't dimer and i don't hate the guy at all. The facts are the facts buddy. How many Heisman's, National Titles and wins vs Florida combined did he have in College?

Most people who have Boston Red Sox avatars also like the Patriots was my point.Sorry should have spelled it out for you.
He has 0 to your questions above but I enjoyed watching him play.Dan Marino has no Super Bowls but I enjoyed watching him.I will try to keep you in mind next time I make your/MINE picks for top 5 college football players.