Truth-telling Montero will get another chance
June 30, 2017
Miguel Montero, former Cubs backup catcher, spoke the truth Tuesday after the Washington Nationals stole seven bases on him and Chicago right-hander Jake Arrieta.
Montero told reporters the blame didn't rest solely with him, but also with the right-hander's slow delivery to the plate. Then, on Wednesday, the 12-year veteran and two-time All-Star was shown the door, designated for assignment, for stating the facts in public.
How ironic that this happened in Washington, where it seems the politicians and media are constantly debating what the truth really is.
Montero has been entirely substandard at throwing out would-be base-stealers in his three seasons with the Cubs, nailing about 14 percent. He has been especially dismal this season: He has started 28 games (nine with Arrieta) and has thrown out only 1 of 32.
But Arrieta is bad, too: In three seasons with the Cubs, runners have stolen bases with an 85 percent success rate against him.
Teammates aren't supposed to call each other out.
After the Tuesday game, Montero was asked about the seven Nationals steals and said, "It really sucked because the stolen bases go to me. And, when you really look at it, the pitcher doesn't give me any time. So, it's like, 'Yeah, OK, Miggy can't throw nobody out.' But my pitcher doesn't hold anybody on."
On Wednesday, Arrieta said, "There's a lot of honesty there. I didn't do him any favors."
It didn't matter at that point. Cubs president Theo Epstein had convened general manager Jed Hoyer and manager Joe Maddon, and they decided it was time to move on.
"We felt like the things that he said were sort of against what we're trying to accomplish right now," Hoyer said. "We wouldn't have made this decision were it not for those comments."
Maybe it was time for this union to end, even though Montero was part of the 2016 World Series champions and a solid offensive contributor when in the lineup this season.
In a radio interview on Wednesday morning, Cubs first baseman Anthony Rizzo said, "When you start pointing fingers, that just labels you as a selfish player. ... We have another catcher that throws out everybody."
First-stringer Wilson Contreras throws out 34 percent (he has caught Arrieta in seven starts).
Fine. So Montero gets the "bad teammate" label for the moment. And the facts say he still is poor at controlling the running game.
But please don't think you've seen the last of him. He will play again, soon -- and likely for a contender. That's because his bat will win games, and much is forgiven for those who know how to win.
Montero hit .286 with an .805 on-base-plus-slugging percentage in 112 plate appearances this season. Few teams have a backup catcher with numbers like that.
Almost certainly no one will claim him off waivers and take on a portion of the $14 million he is earning this season. But once he is past the waiver system -- and the Cubs are on the hook for most of his salary -- some team will grab him up.
Houston backup catcher Evan Gattis has a .751 OPS. Washington backup catcher Jose Lobaton has a .448 OPS. Cleveland backup catcher Roberto Perez has a .527 OPS.
So, if you want to understand something about baseball, keep an eye on Montero.
Still, there is something else here. If Montero hadn't spoken his truth in public, he likely would still be with the Cubs. There is a pecking order in baseball clubhouses. A backup catcher isn't supposed to critique a starting pitcher, apparently even if he is a longtime veteran who has been an All-Star. He crossed that line and doesn't get to play for the Cubs anymore.
But he is still a good player. And it takes a transgression far worse than that to keep a productive player out of the game.
Montero, despite his shortcomings, spoke a truth that even Arrieta called "honesty." Slowing an opponents' running game is on both the pitcher and the catcher.
Now we watch and see what happens to Montero. Maybe he ends up on another World Series champion. Maybe speaking the truth will come with some measure of justice.
June 30, 2017
Miguel Montero, former Cubs backup catcher, spoke the truth Tuesday after the Washington Nationals stole seven bases on him and Chicago right-hander Jake Arrieta.
Montero told reporters the blame didn't rest solely with him, but also with the right-hander's slow delivery to the plate. Then, on Wednesday, the 12-year veteran and two-time All-Star was shown the door, designated for assignment, for stating the facts in public.
How ironic that this happened in Washington, where it seems the politicians and media are constantly debating what the truth really is.
Montero has been entirely substandard at throwing out would-be base-stealers in his three seasons with the Cubs, nailing about 14 percent. He has been especially dismal this season: He has started 28 games (nine with Arrieta) and has thrown out only 1 of 32.
But Arrieta is bad, too: In three seasons with the Cubs, runners have stolen bases with an 85 percent success rate against him.
Teammates aren't supposed to call each other out.
After the Tuesday game, Montero was asked about the seven Nationals steals and said, "It really sucked because the stolen bases go to me. And, when you really look at it, the pitcher doesn't give me any time. So, it's like, 'Yeah, OK, Miggy can't throw nobody out.' But my pitcher doesn't hold anybody on."
On Wednesday, Arrieta said, "There's a lot of honesty there. I didn't do him any favors."
It didn't matter at that point. Cubs president Theo Epstein had convened general manager Jed Hoyer and manager Joe Maddon, and they decided it was time to move on.
"We felt like the things that he said were sort of against what we're trying to accomplish right now," Hoyer said. "We wouldn't have made this decision were it not for those comments."
Maybe it was time for this union to end, even though Montero was part of the 2016 World Series champions and a solid offensive contributor when in the lineup this season.
In a radio interview on Wednesday morning, Cubs first baseman Anthony Rizzo said, "When you start pointing fingers, that just labels you as a selfish player. ... We have another catcher that throws out everybody."
First-stringer Wilson Contreras throws out 34 percent (he has caught Arrieta in seven starts).
Fine. So Montero gets the "bad teammate" label for the moment. And the facts say he still is poor at controlling the running game.
But please don't think you've seen the last of him. He will play again, soon -- and likely for a contender. That's because his bat will win games, and much is forgiven for those who know how to win.
Montero hit .286 with an .805 on-base-plus-slugging percentage in 112 plate appearances this season. Few teams have a backup catcher with numbers like that.
Almost certainly no one will claim him off waivers and take on a portion of the $14 million he is earning this season. But once he is past the waiver system -- and the Cubs are on the hook for most of his salary -- some team will grab him up.
Houston backup catcher Evan Gattis has a .751 OPS. Washington backup catcher Jose Lobaton has a .448 OPS. Cleveland backup catcher Roberto Perez has a .527 OPS.
So, if you want to understand something about baseball, keep an eye on Montero.
Still, there is something else here. If Montero hadn't spoken his truth in public, he likely would still be with the Cubs. There is a pecking order in baseball clubhouses. A backup catcher isn't supposed to critique a starting pitcher, apparently even if he is a longtime veteran who has been an All-Star. He crossed that line and doesn't get to play for the Cubs anymore.
But he is still a good player. And it takes a transgression far worse than that to keep a productive player out of the game.
Montero, despite his shortcomings, spoke a truth that even Arrieta called "honesty." Slowing an opponents' running game is on both the pitcher and the catcher.
Now we watch and see what happens to Montero. Maybe he ends up on another World Series champion. Maybe speaking the truth will come with some measure of justice.
Comment