Peyton Manning

[10DimeBry]

those 4 or 5 picks he threw in that game had nothing to do adverse conditions. he was just awful that day!

See even INDY fan agrees with me. Again my point isnt that manning is not a top 5 QB. thats not my point. He is solid. But when it counts he's a no show plain and simple. Thank you musclemann.

[molta02]

Look, football games, especially in the playoffs, are won on both sides of the ball. However, it is hard to discount the fact that Manning has not played well in big playoff games. That is a fact.

[10DimeBry]

rook,

please read post 113 pal

[10DimeBry]

Look, football games, especially in the playoffs, are won on both sides of the ball. However, it is hard to discount the fact that Manning has not played well in big playoff games. That is a fact.

BINGO

[TheRook]

NO NO NO i'm saying that manning has been a ZERO in big games. And that is a FACT. Did his D let him down yes. But you cant blame just the D. And if thats your arguement then why arent you proping the colts D for last nights victory and not Manning???

I thought I did when I called them a complete team...offense, defense and special teams. It was a while ago..but it's there.

And yes, I read post 113...bwhahahahahahahahahah

It's true...i'll get Tommy No Knees to find you.

[10DimeBry]

I thought I did when I called them a complete team...offense, defense and special teams. It was a while ago..but it's there.

And yes, I read post 113...bwhahahahahahahahahah

It's true...i'll get Tommy No Knees to find you.

lol did you see INDY's D. Brady's WR's at times were so open he could have punted the ball to them.

[jhedrick]

10dime!!!

Glad that I could start a thread that brought a lot of interest. I dont mean to say at all that you are unintelligent about football. My quote was that your debate about Manning not being an elite QB was unintelligent.

That being said I believe manning makes his recievers much better. Reggie Wayne did nothing b4 Manning. neither did Troy Walters, now they are good receivers?
Much like MJordan made everyone else better around him all of the skill positions players on offense including EJames and MHarrison benefit from Mannings greatness!!!

Not only do I think he is the best I've ever seen, I think he will go down in a very small list of the greatest of all time. I understand he will need to win multiple Super Bowls for that to happen but I hope for his sake he can be associated with a defense as dominant as the patriots have been the last few years.

Either way thanks for the passionate debate!!! GL 2 ya brotha!!!

[10DimeBry]

10dime!!!

Glad that I could start a thread that brought a lot of interest. I dont mean to say at all that you are unintelligent about football. My quote was that your debate about Manning not being an elite QB was unintelligent.

That being said I believe manning makes his recievers much better. Reggie Wayne did nothing b4 Manning. neither did Troy Walters, now they are good receivers?
Much like MJordan made everyone else better around him all of the skill positions players on offense including EJames and MHarrison benefit from Mannings greatness!!!

Not only do I think he is the best I've ever seen, I think he will go down in a very small list of the greatest of all time. I understand he will need to win multiple Super Bowls for that to happen but I hope for his sake he can be associated with a defense as dominant as the patriots have been the last few years.

Either way thanks for the passionate debate!!! GL 2 ya brotha!!!

no problem here bro. its all good. I dont mind a good debate. This made my day fly by. Thanks for starting this thread.

[10DimeBry]

I just wanted to say thanks for starting this thread jhedrick. I hope my posts in here cleared alot of this situation up. Any other issues anyone has feel free to just ask me. I'm here for you all.

-Spark

[jhedrick]

no problem here bro. its all good. I dont mind a good debate. This made my day fly by. Thanks for starting this thread.

NO DOUBT!!! and no point was better than "we'll all see wont we???"

[kbsooner21]

I can't even read a thread where my opinion is different than 10dimedumbass! Everyone he doesn't like is a choker.

[TheRook]

Look, football games, especially in the playoffs, are won on both sides of the ball. However, it is hard to discount the fact that Manning has not played well in big playoff games. That is a fact.

Playoff record 3-4

average in 7 games....

22-34 (65%) 278 yds 2 TD 1 INT

3 of the 7 games he threw for over 300 yards, and last year threw for over 458 yards against the Broncos.


The last two years he's run into the Super bowl Champs....but to say he chokes in the big games, is just not true.

[JBC13]

Good stuff guys!! I am packing it in for the day.

But Manning is still a CHOKE...lol.

[vinnyvegas]

I can't even read a thread where my opinion is different than 10dimedumbass! Everyone he doesn't like is a choker.

Can I nominate this as the funniest quote of the day...LOL

[kbsooner21]

I was just messing with him, but he knows it's true