Would you buy a car from ex-dogfighter Michael Vick?

[mavskidd02]

You can't compare human life to animal life imo.

This.

Guy admits he fucked up, serves his punishment determined by the Court . Comes back to the NFL and plays well, keeps his mouth shut and doesn't bother anybody.

Let's hang 'em.

[mavskidd02]

It takes a lot to change....most of us value life...mike vick didn't..and maybe still doesn't except now he needs to stay on a straight path in order to make millions....his soul is still rotten and in the end he'll be judged by god and not us

"In the end he'll be judged by god and not us"

Well if that's the case, who are you to say:

"his soul is still rotten"

How do you have any idea about Vick's soul?

[DAREALDEAL]

I don't...but im judging him and feel he is scum....I don't know if he is reformers or not but can care less about him......and im on my dank phone right now trying to type!

[10DimeBry]

Lets be honest. People only praise Vick now because he is playing well. No one really knows him. Heck no one even really knows if he really has changed or not. People just want to feel good and cheer him cause he is playing good football. People are shallow and are often too quick to forget the past.

[harold_bush]

Totally different scenario. The victim was not tortured and killed .

For the life of me I can not understand how anyone can defend someone like this. I do not care what he paid back to SOCIETY. How about the poor creatures that he had tortured and killed?

Wow, brilliant. A woman that is raped is often tortured for the rest of her life.

Also, let's not make a dumb comparison between people and dogs. What Vick did was reprehensible, but dogs aren't people. Killing a dog is sick, but clearly not the same as killing a person. Killing a squirrel is not the same as killing a dog. Killing a roach isn't the same as killing a squirrel.

[harold_bush]

That is great that you can forgive and forget like that. I commend you for that. For me, I judge future behavior with past behavior.

One more question and I am done. Would you allow Vick to watch and take care of your dog for a month??

Completely irrelevant question to whether or not he deserves a second chance.

Would you propose happens to Vick? Would you want him to remain in jail the rest of his life? Be put to death? Not be allowed to work in the NFL and be on welfare or sell drugs?

[harold_bush]

"In the end he'll be judged by god and not us"

Well if that's the case, who are you to say:

"his soul is still rotten"

How do you have any idea about Vick's soul?

good point.........unless he IS God.

[Spark]

Also, let's not make a dumb comparison between people and dogs. What Vick did was reprehensible, but dogs aren't people. Killing a dog is sick, but clearly not the same as killing a person. Killing a squirrel is not the same as killing a dog. Killing a roach isn't the same as killing a squirrel.

Where did I compare humans with dogs??


Don't quote me and then put words in my mouth.

[Spark]

Completely irrelevant question to whether or not he deserves a second chance.

Would you propose happens to Vick? Would you want him to remain in jail the rest of his life? Be put to death? Not be allowed to work in the NFL and be on welfare or sell drugs?

That sounds like a plan to me!!!

[vols fan]

Where did I compare humans with dogs??


Don't quote me and then put words in my mouth.

Damn. Thats going to make two of us from Georgia you don't like anymore.

[harold_bush]

Where did I compare humans with dogs??


Don't quote me and then put words in my mouth.

"Totally different scenario. The victim was not tortured and killed"

You said the situation is totally different b/c the victim (a human) was not tortured and killed. That implies that the situation would be the same if the victim (a human) was tortured and killed.

[harold_bush]

That sounds like a plan to me!!!

Wow, and I thought I was tough on crime!

[Spark]

Damn. Thats going to make two of us from Georgia you don't like anymore.

Another one putting words in my mouth

[vols fan]

Another one putting words in my mouth

WORDS ? That would be what you have not said to me in a month. C'mon Spark we talked everyday for years and now nothing said between us for a month.

[Big Country 5]

I aint never liked Vick,but they made an example out of him.I love animals,but the guy did the time.Fuck,OJ got away with murder,but people wanna hang Vick.Guess I dont get it.