Where Does Brett Favre Rank......

[jt4545]

Top 5 for sure, without a doubt!!!!!

[jcindaville]

JC,

I have met Johnny U - he was a next door neighbor to my wifes Uncle. It was at is duaghter's (wifes cousin) wedding.

Great guy, very down to earth. He was smaller than I imagined cause as a kid he was one of my heroes. His one hand was crippled from injuries.

There is another statue of him right outside Ravens stadium.


BTW, I saw you had a tough day yesterday, bring it back this week. You had to admire how the Ravens shut down Denver, told you not to go down with Denver

Well, you were right, and I was wrong. There is your feedback

[griswold]

Just about right. He has been damn fortunate to play on some good teams with good players.

Brett Favre has been surrounded by mediocre receivers his whole career.

Billy Schroeder??
Antonio Freeman??
Robert Brooks??
These guys were the leading receivers on his team in many years.

If he had a randy Moss, jerry Rice or equivalent player his numbers would be even gaudier.

I put him about fifth behind Montana, Unitas, Marino and maybe a couple others

[wayne1218]

Brett Favre has been surrounded by mediocre receivers his whole career.

Billy Schroeder??
Antonio Freeman??
Robert Brooks??
These guys were the leading receivers on his team in many years.

If he had a randy Moss, jerry Rice or equivalent player his numbers would be even gaudier.

I put him about fifth behind Montana, Unitas, Marino and maybe a couple others

What about Sterling Sharpe???

[wayne1218]

1) Marino

2) Johnny Unitas

3) John Elway

4) Dan Fouts

5) Joe Montana

6) Steve Young

7) Peyton Manning

8) Joe Namath

9)Jim Kelly

10)Warren Moon

11) Farve

12) Troy Aikman

A guy at #1 with no ring and Warren Moon on a list that Brady didn't make? You are on crack!

[wayne1218]

Marino was the better QB

If Marino played to the age of 86 like Favre he would still have the record

Marino had a HOF coach that couldn't win with him yet won without him, 2 premier WR's and a defense called the "Killer B's" who were not that bad at all. Marino couldn't EVER get it done, period. Zero rings prove it.

[jcindaville]

A guy at #1 with no ring and Warren Moon on a list that Brady didn't make? You are on crack!

Bradshaw has 4 rings and he didnt make his list either

Dan fouts, sorry, no way he is that high on my list.

Each to his own i guess

[wayne1218]

Bradshaw has 4 rings and he didnt make his list either

Dan fouts, sorry, no way he is that high on my list.

Each to his own i guess

I agree about to each their own but some people and their hatred towards certain players make out lists that have them looking absolutely FOOLISH.

[wayne1218]

Dan fouts, sorry, no way he is that high on my list.

Seriously, he has Fouts ahead of Joe Montana. Did Fouts ever beat Montana? What a joke!

[wayne1218]

I would rank Favre in the 5-6 range but being the career record holder for INT's can't be overlooked imo.

[jcindaville]

I agree about to each their own but some people and their hatred towards certain players make out lists that have them looking absolutely FOOLISH.

I agree, i am by no means a Pat fan, but Tom Brady is the shit.

Troy Brown and the other cast of decent but not great WR and virtually never a running game, and look at that cat and how many rings he is sporting.

Brady is definitley in my top 10, and if the game was on the line and i needed one drive with time running out. Give me Montana and Brady.

[jcindaville]

Bradshaw had awesome talent around him, and I mean awesome. But he did produce with that talent.

Didnt hurt to have the Steele curtain always giving you the ball in good field position either.

[jcindaville]

Seriously, he has Fouts ahead of Joe Montana. Did Fouts ever beat Montana? What a joke!

Fouts, Kelly, and Moon dont make my top 10. No rings and Kelly had some real talent around him, plus he got 4 shots at a ring.

[wayne1218]

I agree, i am by no means a Pat fan, but Tom Brady is the shit.

Troy Brown and the other cast of decent but not great WR and virtually never a running game, and look at that cat and how many rings he is sporting.

Brady is definitley in my top 10, and if the game was on the line and i needed one drive with time running out. Give me Montana and Brady.

Even NE fans struggle to name the WR's and RB's on the 3 SB winning teams. You can't find a guy with 2 or 3 rings with LESS talent around him on offense. It is amazing really. Seriously, i guarantee nobody can name them without looking them up. Antwoin Smith at RB and Troy Brown at WR? I don't even remember the other guys in the 1st 2 SB's. I know Dillon was there for the 3rd and who were the WR's with him? Anybody?? People talk about Moss like he was there for them and he wasn't. The 1st year he was in NE and Brady had a WR for the 1st time in his career, Brady and Moss reset the record books at their positions. They were the 1st team to complete a (16-0) season and they had the most prolific offense in NFL History. Whether you like Brady or not, you would be a fool to exclude him from the list. I don't want to hear about Belichick being the reason either because he was an awful coach his whole career until Brady came along to make him look great!

[jcindaville]

I can name one WR for the Pats

Tony Deion Branch, Jr. (born, July 18, 1979, in Albany, Georgia) (Resides in Carmel, Indiana) is an American football wide receiver who currently plays for the Seattle Seahawks of the NFL. He is 5'9" and 193 pounds and was picked by New England in the second round of the 2002 NFL Draft out of the University of Louisville. Branch was named the Most Valuable Player of Super Bowl XXXIX on February 6, 2005,



from DaVille