Heisman Trophy Opinions!!

[wayne1218]

Brennan will never win it because he plays for Hawaii. It's not right but it is what it is.

Chase Daniel has a shot if he can play great and Win the next 2 games!

[wayne1218]

After watching McFadden today, I couldn't vote for anyone else. That cat is ridiculous! He was a man among boys today against the #1 team in the nation at their OWN house.

My top 3 votes go to

1. Darren McFadden
2. Tim Tebow
3. Chase Daniel

AGREED!

[meaiken]

Chris Wienke was a senior citizen when he won it.

[meaiken]

McFadden did look great

[TMAC951]

Oh yeah thats right. I should have said no sophomore has won it.. thats the #1 thing i think will keep tebow from winning it and also throw in the fact that the voters know for a fact he will be back next season..

[wayne1218]

McFadden also rushed for 321 Yards 3 weeks ago against South Carolina on National T.V.

Yes .... 321 yards rushing in one game!!!!!!

[TMAC951]

McFadden also rushed for 321 Yards 3 weeks ago against South Carolina on National T.V.

Yes .... 321 yards rushing in one game!!!!!!

But throw in the fact that he was also shut down (less than 75 yards if im not mistaken) on prime time national television against Auburn

[TMAC951]

Mcfadden has had 3 games less than 100 yards rushing this season..

43 yards VS Auburn
61 yards VS FIU
88 yards VS Miss. State

[DBURGH]

McFadden is a beast when i bet against him,,,he is a mouse when i bet on him...... Tebow is incredible,,,but who knows,,it should be interesting..

[wayne1218]

But throw in the fact that he was also shut down (less than 75 yards if im not mistaken) on prime time national television against Auburn

Yes, that was a rough one for McFadden. Tebow struggled at LSU though and when people compare what both did playing @ #1 ... they won't forget it. Considering a Sophomore has never Won and they know Tebow will be back next year, i really see McFadden winning this thing now. His only chance was to have a HUGE game today and he had it. I won't be shocked if Tebow wins it though. They are both deserving!

[TMAC951]

Yes, that was a rough one for McFadden. Tebow struggled at LSU though and when people compare what both did playing @ #1 ... they won't forget it. Considering a Sophomore has never Won and they know Tebow will be back next year, i really see McFadden winning this thing now. His only chance was to have a HUGE game today and he had it. I won't be shocked if Tebow wins it though. They are both deserving!

I agree with that.. Would be nice for one of them to win it this year and mcfadden come back next season and do it all over and we can be talking this same talk this time next season

[skyz]

McFadden

[harold_bush]

Tebow, first player in the history of college football to rush for 20 TDs and pass for 20 TDs. Oh yeah, he did it in the best conference in football. Yeah, that is an easy one.

[harold_bush]

What about Colt Brennen Look at his numbers

if Brennan didn't even getting invited last year when he lead the nation in virtually every category, including setting several all time records, he ain't gonna win it with half the numbers and missing 3 games this year.

[Celtics86]

McFadden plays on a team that cannot throw the ball. There are always 9 people in the box, and he still gets the job done. Tebow is good, but he has the ball in his hands more, so he has more chances to get stats. Tebow also has a lot better players on his side of the ball, plus he is in a gimmick offense. There is no doubt that if I was an NFL GM I would take Mcfadden over Tebow. One more thing, Houston Nutt is the best game day coach in the country. Wish he had more talent.