Heisman Trophy Opinions!!

[TMAC951]

After today I honestly think it comes down to McFadden and Tim Tebow.. I thought maybe Oregon's QB could win it but now that he is hurt I think it comes down between these two. Anybody else have anyone that they think can sneak up and maybe win it?

[peave]

If Missouri wins next 2 games against Kansas and Big 12 Championship with Daniels. He could surpsise everyone. Tebow probably favorite, but pretty wide open this year.

[3ebRocks]

Love McFadden, but Tebow more valuable and on a better team. Not to mention his numbers are unprecedented. QB is a harder position to play. A more important position on the field and McFadden doesnt even average the most ypc on his team. He is great, but Tebow deserves it.

[GrandPa]

You wouldn't be wrong if you voted for Tebow or McFadden. Both are off-the-charts phenoms who dominate at this level.

Tebow is the only player ever to throw for and run for 20+ TDs in the same season, and that has to impress someone. And McFadden has redefined his position, and is responsible for a unique offensive set designed to exploit his speed and superiority.

Two virtuosos. Only one winner. I hate the Heisman anyway because it is supposed to represent the best or most outstanding college football player, and in all actuality it is an overhyped overblown award given to " the best skill position player on a BCS Championship contender."

[wayne1218]

I would take McFadden!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


He just went on the road against number 1 and owned them. Tebow didn't pull that one out!

[soonerbud]

Without a doubt McFadden..........he definately deserves it after today........I agree with Wayne, Tebow couldn't get it done. That cat McFadden is just better.

[TMAC951]

I honestly think the 2 things that is going to kill Tebow and his chances at winning the heisman is this..

#1. He team has lost 3 games
#2. He is only a sophomore and to my knowledge there has never been a sophomore or even a junior to win the heisman trophy.. He will be back next season and could very well win it then.. With that being said i think McFadden wins it.. But i agree with a previous post that IF Missouri wins out their QB can sneak up and steal some votes..

[meaiken]

Wasn't Matt Leinart a JR when he won it?

[meaiken]

Reggie Bush and Jason White were also Jr's

[meaiken]

Roger Staubach was a jr also and Archi Griffin (the 1st time)

[meaiken]

Hershal Walker also and 5 others

desmond Howard, Barry Sanders

[meaiken]

What about Colt Brennen Look at his numbers

[mrbenny]

chase daniel. period

[wayne1218]

I honestly think the 2 things that is going to kill Tebow and his chances at winning the heisman is this..

#1. He team has lost 3 games
#2. He is only a sophomore and to my knowledge there has never been a sophomore or even a junior to win the heisman trophy.. He will be back next season and could very well win it then.. With that being said i think McFadden wins it.. But i agree with a previous post that IF Missouri wins out their QB can sneak up and steal some votes..

No Freshman or Sophomore has ever won it but 16 Junior's have, including 3 of the last 4 years. Tebow is a Sophomore and McFadden is a Junior. McFadden is going to Win the Heisman!

[kbsooner21]

After watching McFadden today, I couldn't vote for anyone else. That cat is ridiculous! He was a man among boys today against the #1 team in the nation at their OWN house.

My top 3 votes go to

1. Darren McFadden
2. Tim Tebow
3. Chase Daniel