Who's the worst quarterback to win a Super Bowl?

[wayne1218]

Yeh but he also had 2 that were less then 11!!

I realize that but everybody is assuming the QB who had that rating Twice is the one playing in the SB. I have not seen anyone who expects the Chicago QB who had a rating over 100 Seven times to be there. Why is that? 7 to 2 seems to favor the great Rex showing up doesn't it?

[frankb03]

Correct. I would take Grossman before all of these winners .......

Brad Johnson
Trent Dildo
Doug Williams
Mark Rypien
Jeff Hostetler

I agree with your list except Hostetler. He was voted to a Pro Bowl in 1994. He had some decent years with Oakland. He had 8 straight seasons with a QB rating in the 80s. That would rank him about 10-15 in the QB rating this season. He was also very mobile.

[wayne1218]

I agree with your list except Hostetler. He was voted to a Pro Bowl in 1994. He had some decent years with Oakland. He had 8 straight seasons with a QB rating in the 80s. That would rank him about 10-15 in the QB rating this season. He was also very mobile.

I wouldn't have a problem removing him from my list. I've always liked the Raiders and i used to like him there. You're right, he wasn't bad at all, just not that flashy i guess.

[dave T]

No Brainer: Trent Dilfer

[RDOG55]

I think Trent Dilfer was the worst ever. Grossman actually had a game this year with a rating of "0"

[worm]

It is hard to play any worse then Rothlisberger did and still win