A Question For The Entire Forum

[frankb03]

I would love to hear you justify your obsession with bashing McNabb but I really don't care. You and I both know what McNabb has done in his career. You never give credit where credit is due and don't expect you to start.

I'm not obsessed at all. I simply agree with Rush's comments. IMO opinion McNabb is a GOOD NFL QB who's enjoying a GOOD career. I do not consider him great. His career has proven he's NOT great. He's played for a franchise that has been the best in a very mediocre conference the past half dozen years. In that time span there's 10-12 QB that not only would have brought the Eagles to more Super Bowls but probably would have won at least one. His performances in the NFC championship games have been disappointing including one horrible game at home vs. Carolina.

I give lots of credit when due. Brady? Great. Brees very impressive. Bringing two floundering teams to the playoffs. Rivers? Great start to his career. Palmer? 3rd best QB in football. McNair best black NFL QB. Young will surpass both McNabb and McNair.

Thanks for asking. I'm glad you don't care.

[THEV30]

I'm not obsessed at all. I simply agree with Rush's comments. IMO opinion McNabb is a GOOD NFL QB who's enjoying a GOOD career. I do not consider him great. His career has proven he's NOT great. He's played for a franchise that has been the best in a very mediocre conference the past half dozen years. In that time span there's 10-12 QB that not only would have brought the Eagles to more Super Bowls but probably would have won at least one. His performances in the NFC championship games have been disappointing including one horrible game at home vs. Carolina.

I give lots of credit when due. Brady? Great. Brees very impressive. Bringing two floundering teams to the playoffs. Rivers? Great start to his career. Palmer? 3rd best QB in football. McNair best black NFL QB. Young will surpass both McNabb and McNair.

Thanks for asking. I'm glad you don't care.

THEN AGAIN THIS COULD HAVE BEEN MCNABBS YEAR BEFORE HE GOT HURT HIS NUMBERS WERE LOOKING PRETTY IMPRESSIVE BUT WE ARE PAST THAT LETS GO GARCIA BRING IT HOME BABY. E.A.G.L.E.S. EAGLES

[frankb03]

THEN AGAIN THIS COULD HAVE BEEN MCNABBS YEAR BEFORE HE GOT HURT HIS NUMBERS WERE LOOKING PRETTY IMPRESSIVE BUT WE ARE PAST THAT LETS GO GARCIA BRING IT HOME BABY. E.A.G.L.E.S. EAGLES

Garcia has done more with the Eagles this season than McNabb. The Eagles were floundering under McNabb's leadership. What was the Eagles record with McNabb behind center? Without?

ENOUGH SAID. I journeyman QB has performed better.

[THEV30]

Garcia has done more with the Eagles this season than McNabb. The Eagles were floundering under McNabb's leadership. What was the Eagles record with McNabb behind center? Without?

ENOUGH SAID. I journeyman QB has performed better.

I AGREE I THINK THE BEST THING THAT EVER HAPPENED THIS SEASON IS GARCIA THAT BEING SAID WE STILL DONT KNOW HOW MCNABB WOULD HAVE TURNED OUT. IT DONT MATTER WE ARE ROLLIN WITH GARCIA AND ARE D IS FINALLY STARTING TO PLAY WELL WATCH OUT FOR THE TEAM THAT WAS COUNTED OUT.

[BigMike]

What control does McNabb have over the defense? The Eagles had what I think was the #1 rated offense before he went down. Was McNabb playing corner when Burress caught a TD in OT in the 2nd game of the season? Was he playing LB when Jones Drew ran all over them? Garcia is getting the job done and I can't say McNabb would have turned the team around but this winning streak is mostly because the defense has been playing well and causing turnovers. To say that Garcia is a better QB then McNabb is hilarious and moronic. Maybe in this spot he gave the team a spark McNabb wasn't capable of at the time. I'll give you that.

[THEV30]

What control does McNabb have over the defense? The Eagles had what I think was the #1 rated offense before he went down. Was McNabb playing corner when Burress caught a TD in OT in the 2nd game of the season? Was he playing LB when Jones Drew ran all over them? Garcia is getting the job done and I can't say McNabb would have turned the team around but this winning streak is mostly because the defense has been playing well and causing turnovers. To say that Garcia is a better QB then McNabb is hilarious and moronic. Maybe in this spot he gave the team a spark McNabb wasn't capable of at the time. I'll give you that.

I AGREE THE D, DAWKINS HAS BEEN STEPPING UP BIG LIKE I SAID BEFORE WE DONT KNOW WERE WE WOULD BE RIGHT NOW WITH MCNABB BUT WE KNOW WERE WE ARE WITH GARCIA 3 ROAD WINS AGAINST DIVISION.ON ARE WAY TO WINNING THE DIVISION AND WE BEAT DALLAS TWICE THIS YEAR THAT IS THE BEST THING OF ALL.BY THE WAY I WOULD DEFINETLY KEEP MCNABB OVER GARCIA.

[Spiccoli]

There is no way in hell Green Bay is going to win in Chicago. The Bears D will be on the field, and if Griese plays, he will do fine. Remember he lead Tampa into the playoffs last year with early success before he got hurt and Simms took over. Lovie Smith demands excellence at all times from these guys, and the Pack doesn't have the players to match up.

With all the expectations of a Washington win, I am definitely taking the Giants. Even the talking heads on ESPN picked Washington.

'Nuff said.

P.S. I love Philly in the playoffs...they are on a roll but I don't see them in the big game.

[3rdmckid]

top rated offense only by total yardage numbers, not by wins or even pts scored. b careful of stats, they can b used in any fashion you choose to use them in. i think this is why some people can get sucked in when they hear numbers/stats like those...............

[KJ1000]

This is not my research or quote, just something from ESPN radio 2 days ago...Giants are 3-0 when needing to win the game to make the playoffs over the past couple of years...take it with a grain of salt as I have done zero research on this

However, I am taking the Giants for the exact reason posted...EVERYONE is picking the Redskins...yes, Shockey is out, but Redskins are not knee deep in talent themselves...give me the team that choked but can still get in the playoffs...nothing crazy here, but it is one of my weekly picks...

Best of luck in whatever you play!

kj