Brady Or Manning? Merrill Hoge Picks Manning

[frankb03]

I think Manning is the better QB however.

Manning might be the better QB but Brady is the better money QB.

Arod has put up better stats in the regular season than Jeter. Everyone would take Jeter over GayRod.

[wayne1218]

Weapons in the NFL is overrated. The talent level in the NFL is very close. It's the best of the best. Put Branch, Givens and other Patriot receivers on Indy and they'll also be pro bowlers.

Brady has the best weapons of all. A great offensive line with a great defense.

All that being said. I'd take Brady over P Manning in a heartbeat.

BS Frank. Tell Montana that Rice, Taylor, Craig & Lott were overrated and he will laugh in your face. Ask the same of Aikman about Irvin, Emmitt, Sanders and the other 10 hall of fame lineman he played with. Elway? Ask him if he wins without Romo, Davis or that D-Line. Bradshaw? How does he win w/out Hall of Famers EVERYWHERE around him on offense or defense?

How many Patriots are going to the Hall of Fame besides Brady frank?? Maybe the kicker and maybe, maybe Harrison? Give me a break!

He is the only QB to ever win multiple titles without Hall of fame talent surrounding him. Name another who won multiple times and i will point out all the historic talent around him. Who played with Brady in their 1st win? Most people can't name more than a few players and that's a testament to Brady!

[gbell]

Manning might be the better QB but Brady is the better money QB.

Arod has put up better stats in the regular season than Jeter. Everyone would take Jeter over GayRod.

I agree with that statement about Manning being better but Brady more clutch. And of course everyone would want Jeter b/c of clutch but that's a tough comparison to football just with the way baseball is set up more invidually. Manning can be spot on, but doesn't matter if guys drop passes, O-line breaks down, etc. And it's impossible to compare Brady v Manning with the differences in teams, coaching, etc. With ALL things being equal (which I realize is impossible) Manning wins hands down. To me, he's a better coach on the field as far as play calling. And I know NE/Brady fans throw up the 3 Super Bowls, but I thought the thread was about QB's, not teams. And take away an interesting tuck, and it's 2 SB's.