Brady Or Manning? Merrill Hoge Picks Manning

[musclemann]

Proof This Guy Is A Idiot. 10 Times Out Of 10 I Will Pick Brady, End Of Story.

[Three Jack]

imo, better passer = Manning. Better QB = Brady.

[Three Jack]

But, to answer your original post, Hoge is whacked...he just says some things to get a reaction...didn't he say that Leinart wasn't worty of a first round selection? too many blows to the head for Merrill.

[jmarty6969]

hahahahaha i couldnt go wrong with either one of them brady has the better team fyi................but u have to love both these qbs..................if peyton had a line be would be more scarey then brady but hell i be happy with either one of them.......................................peytons line is just like barry sanders lines used to be sucks..........................i know this for fact cause my bengals brought pressure to peyton and we dont pressure anyone here in cincy

[veiner7]

both are tough but I would like to see Brady with Peyton's weapons ( Harrison, Wayne, Clark) and Peyton with Brady's 2 running backs

[larryonion]

I like Bill Simmons take on this today...
http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2...simmons/061103

[griffey_mojo]

Proof This Guy Is A Idiot. 10 Times Out Of 10 I Will Pick Brady, End Of Story.

Proof he's an idiot because he and you wouldn't pick Brady?

Whatever man...

[musclemann]

Proof he's an idiot because he and you wouldn't pick Brady?

Whatever man...

EITHER YOUR STUPID OR JUST TRYING TO PISS ME OFF. I SAID I WOULD TAKE BRADY EVERY TIME. SEE YOUR UP TO YOUR SAME BULLSHIT.

[Mike1]

imo, better passer = Manning. Better QB = Brady.

I totally agree. Manning is a better passer, but Brady is a better leader. Manning=Marino, Brady=Montana

[wayne1218]

hahahahaha i couldnt go wrong with either one of them brady has the better team fyi................but u have to love both these qbs..................if peyton had a line be would be more scarey then brady but hell i be happy with either one of them.......................................peytons line is just like barry sanders lines used to be sucks..........................i know this for fact cause my bengals brought pressure to peyton and we dont pressure anyone here in cincy

I have to disagree. It may not be great but E. James never complained when he went to one Pro Bowl after another. Peyton had Edge, Harrison, Wayne & Clark ... along with homefield advantage and they STILL couldn't pull it off. Brady has NEVER had the weapons around him on offense to equal what manning works with. Call it what you want but Indy DOMINATED the last few regular seasons and went on to look scared & fragile every time in the post season when the hardware was up for grabs!

[molta02]

Peyton Manning is a pussy

[musclemann]

I have to disagree. It may not be great but E. James never complained when he went to one Pro Bowl after another. Peyton had Edge, Harrison, Wayne & Clark ... along with homefield advantage and they STILL couldn't pull it off. Brady has NEVER had the weapons around him on offense to equal what manning works with. Call it what you want but Indy DOMINATED the last few regular seasons and went on to look scared & fragile every time in the post season when the hardware was up for grabs!

P.S LOOK AT PEYTON STATS IN PLAYOFF AND BOWLS GAMES. STARTING TO SEE A SIMILIAR TREND??????????

[wayne1218]

P.S LOOK AT PEYTON STATS IN PLAYOFF AND BOWLS GAMES. STARTING TO SEE A SIMILIAR TREND??????????

He couldn't beat Fla. and last year after failing many times against N.E., they were set up perfectly at home with N.E. not in the picture and still looked like children among men when Pitt. beat them!

[wayne1218]

You want to talk about the O-Line ... Just look at Edge in Arizona and compare it to his numbers in Indy. Their (Indy) line looks much better when you do!

[10DimeBry]

do i even have to comment?