Should Baseball Adopt Video Replay

[Spark]

Give us your opinion

[jcindaville]

If Rook thinks so

[kbsooner21]

Nope

[Spark]

2 Bad Calls in One Crucial Game

Click here Guys

[BigWeiner]

Hell no! It would ruin the game. How great is instant replay in the NFL? They get the call wrong more often then they did without replay.

[Spark]

I personally hate it .. it makes the game take forever ... every play ... Instant replay ....


Do you allow a pitcher to stand there in the Heat waiting for an umpire to review a call for 10 - 15 minutes???

[BigWeiner]

Imagine if they had instant replay in that Padres/Rockies game. Holliday slides into to home, the umpire calls him safe, the crowd is going crazy, and the umpire gets on the mic and says the Padres manager throw the red flag, the play is under review. The umpire than goes and looks at the film, and he can't freakin she shit, no matter what he says, safe or out, the excitement of the game is ruined.

[Spark]

Imagine if they had instant replay in that Padres/Rockies game. Holliday slides into to home, the umpire calls him safe, the crowd is going crazy, and the umpire gets on the mic and says the Padres manager throw the red flag, the play is under review. The umpire than goes and looks at the film, and he can't freakin she shit, no matter what he says, safe or out, the excitement of the game is ruined.

and on top of that ... How does the umpire get out of the stadium alive??? hahahahahahaha

[BigWeiner]

I personally hate it .. it makes the game take forever ... every play ... Instant replay ....


Do you allow a pitcher to stand there in the Heat waiting for an umpire to review a call for 10 - 15 minutes???

It sucks. In football it's a waste of time. Vernon Davis against the Steelers? Incomplete pass? I would rather the refs just flip a coin to make the call.

[BUD GREGG]

4-5 Hr Baseball Game Benefits No One, Umpires Get 99 Per Cent Of All Calls Correct

[weazel079]

maybe for the playoffs, but otherwise no way.

[wayne1218]

Yes, all 3 of the other major 3 have it and in the end, i want them to get it right. A few extra minutes in a game doesn't bother me. Too many refs and umps with agenda's these days and bad eyes too.

Maybe just for HR calls or something. They DEFINATELY need it for that alone (imo).

[wayne1218]

They could also have an alternate ump that sits in a booth with a t.v. and a :30 clock. It wouldn't be that difficult or time consuming. Give each team 1 or 2 per game

[orientalhawn]

No!!!!!

[BigWeiner]

Yes, all 3 of the other major 3 have it and in the end, i want them to get it right. A few extra minutes in a game doesn't bother me. Too many refs and umps with agenda's these days and bad eyes too.

Maybe just for HR calls or something. They DEFINATELY need it for that alone (imo).

The sports with instant replay get it right? They actually get more calls wrong in football IMO. It seems to work for the NBA, but the NFL is a joke.