The Debt Commission Report
Posted by Erick Erickson (Profile)
Thursday, November 11th at 5:00AM EST
As you wake up this morning, there is a lot of talk about the leaked report of the Debt Commission. Keep in mind that this is not the final report, but a draft passed out by the co-chairs.
What you need to know is pretty straight forward.
Yes, the plan ends the deficit. It does so with lots and lots of spending cuts across the board. There are actually some good suggestions in the plan, but there is one inescapable fact — the proposal has buried in it one trillion dollars in tax increases.
Some of what are defined as tax increases are, in fact, closing loopholes in the tax code that lobbyists have inserted on behalf of clients. But also included is getting rid of the home mortgage deduction. That would amount to a massive, massive tax increase on the middle class.
The reforms suggested for social security are out and out garbage. It is not means tested. It is not “lock boxed”. Payments are cut. Retirement is increased.
This proposal is dead on arrival.
But there is another point that must be made — even were all the proposals, plans, and points adopted it would do no good. Why?
Because until Washington admits that it has exceeded the powers given to it under the constitution the same problems will continue to occur over and over.
The Leviathan knows no bounds and, left to itself to check its own growth it will continue growing. Until we are willing to admit that Article I, Section 8 of the U.S. Constitution gives limited powers to Congress, we are wasting our time.
Reporting from Washington and Los Angeles — President Obama proposed a compromise on the thorny political issue of tax cuts on Monday, describing a tentative agreement that would extend all of the George W. Bush-era reductions set to expire the end of this year and continue unemployment benefits for 13 months. In a televised statement, Obama announced what he called "a framework for a bipartisan agreement" that would temporarily extend the tax cuts for the middle class and for the rich alike. The tentative agreement reached Monday likely means that taxes will not increase on Jan. 1 as originally scheduled. Such a tax increase, “would be a chilling prospect for the American people,” Obama said “I am not willing to let that happen.” Obama defended his decision to compromise as needed for the economic recovery. Recognizing that the agreement could cause problems with some Democrats, who have urged him to stand firm against the Republicans, Obama insisted that it “would be a grave injustice to allow these” tax cuts to expire. ‘We cannot play politics,” Obama said. According to White House officials, the elements of agreement include a payroll tax cut designed to put more money into workers’ pockets in the hope that it will stimulate spending and the economic recovery. The cut would total $120 billion in 2011, about a 2 percentage point drop for a typical worker. Other parts of the agreement include extending jobless benefits for 13 months. About 2 million workers in December and 7 million over the next year would have lost benefits without the agreement. Officials argued that the benefit extension will not only help the millions of families for whom unemployment insurance is a key lifeline, but it will also create more than 600,000 jobs over the next year. The agreement also protects the earned income tax credit, child credit, and the American Opportunity tax credit increases from the Recovery Act, officials said. This represents about $40 billion in tax cuts for the hardest-hit families and students that would have been virtually impossible to achieve outside the context of this deal. Obama met with Democratic congressional leaders on Monday seeking a common position on how to extend the Bush-era tax cuts, an issue that has paralyzed the lame-duck congressional session. Obama has been under pressure from his liberal wing to stand firm against GOP pressure to extend the cuts to all, including the rich. Democrats have pushed to extend the cuts only for the middle class, defined as individuals earning no more than $200,000 a year or families earning no more than $250,000 annually. The White House and Republicans have signaled they are open to a compromise that would extend the cuts for all, at least temporarily. That would be coupled with an extension of unemployment benefits. Earlier in North Carolina, Obama repeated that the economic recovery required movement on the extensions, tax cuts and jobless benefits. He urged all parties to “make sure we're coming up with a solution, even if it's not 100% what I want or 100% what the Republicans want.” The payroll tax would drop from the current 6.2% to 4.2%. Such a cut in payroll taxes would put cash in people’s pockets because the withholding in paychecks would be reduced. Democrats have also discussed an extension of the estate tax so that $5 million could be inherited tax-free and anything more would be taxed at the rate of 35%. Republicans want to continue the current cuts that end estate taxes.
Last edited by Spark; 12-08-2010, 10:42 AM.
Comment
Working...
|
Comment