Where Does Brett Favre Rank......

[mavskidd02]

I'm not the only one that read an earlier post that you'd take Favre in one game over Brady.

You must be the only one.

Seeing as I've said several times, that I WOULDN'T take Favre in a ONE GAME situation.

But then again, you haven't read half of what I've written, you are quoting a lot of stuff, not sure you are reading any of it.

[frankb03]

I admitted I was biased an hour ago.

If you are not going to read people's posts, why are you discussing?

As for why we are debating, Wayne likes to talk a lot, I don't mind explaining to him that Tomy Brady isn't God once in a while.

I know. I READ your original post about being biased. I have read the entire thread.

Most of us know Wayne's a huge homer. In this case I gotta agree with Wayne. IMO Brady is top5. In my first post in this thread I put Favre 10-12. Thus, for me, there's no comparison.

[mavskidd02]

The guy holds the record for most interceptions in the history of the game. Doesn't that say something about accuracy??? Are you counting passes thrown to both teams mavs cuz if you are, you win.

Poor decision making, he takes too many risks. If I had to throw a pass to small window downfield, I'd take Favre over almost anybody.

He throws it hard, and fires it in small windows that make impossible plays seem routine.

And if you don't believe me, you can ask Greg Lewis whether or not Favre can fit in a window.

[frankb03]

if you had one game to win....... and if you lose, you die.....

who would you want to be your quarterback?


would anyone take favre over brady???

Molta also felt you would take Favre over Brady for one game.

[wayne1218]

Poor decision making, he takes too many risks. If I had to throw a pass to small window downfield, I'd take Favre over almost anybody.

He throws it hard, and fires it in small windows that make impossible plays seem routine.

And if you don't believe me, you can ask Greg Lewis whether or not Favre can fit in a window.

A great leader doesn't make poor decisions that many times mavs. You are totally contradicting your leadership argument there.

[mavskidd02]

I know. I READ your original post about being biased. I have read the entire thread.

Most of us know Wayne's a huge homer. In this case I gotta agree with Wayne. IMO Brady is top5. In my first post in this thread I put Favre 10-12. Thus, for me, there's no comparison.

I don't get it? Did I say I would take Favre over Brady? You said I did, I clearly didn't, that seems to me like you are not reading a word of what I'm saying..

I never ranked them in terms of all time, or even overall QB abilites.

I ranked them based on three random categories I chose, that are not the be all, end all, of being a good QB.

[wayne1218]

Molta also felt you would take Favre over Brady for one game.

Until a few posts ago, he said he was "Unsure"

[wayne1218]

I don't get it? Did I say I would take Favre over Brady? You said I did, I clearly didn't, that seems to me like you are not reading a word of what I'm saying..

I never ranked them in terms of all time, or even overall QB abilites.

I ranked them based on three random categories I chose, that are not the be all, end all, of being a good QB.

I asked you to rank Brady All time. Just like you asked of Favre in post 1

[mavskidd02]

A great leader doesn't make poor decisions that many times mavs. You are totally contradicting your leadership argument there.

Favre throws interceptions, we know. If you want to use the same logic everyone uses:

"No shit he holds all the records, he's played for a billion years"

Well then, no shit he holds the INT record.

You can't shit on him for holding one bad record, and holding ten of the best records. He throws interceptions?

By the way:

Brett Favre throws an interception once every 33 pass attempts. Is that really so awful?

He also holds a career 62% completion %.

So relax with all the interception throwing, he's not accurate garbage.

[wayne1218]

Favre throws interceptions, we know. If you want to use the same logic everyone uses:

"No shit he holds all the records, he's played for a billion years"

Well then, no shit he holds the INT record.

You can't shit on him for holding one bad record, and holding ten of the best records. He throws interceptions?

By the way:

Brett Favre throws an interception once every 33 pass attempts. Is that really so awful?

He also holds a career 62% completion %.

So relax with all the interception throwing, he's not accurate garbage.

That is such BS. Does Cal Ripken Jr hold the All time record for errors? No ........

[mavskidd02]

I asked you to rank Brady All time. Just like you asked of Favre in post 1

My ranking of anyone all time would mean very little to you, if you catch my drift, that is why I simply compared Brady and Favre with the only other great QB of this generation

[wayne1218]

My ranking of anyone all time would mean very little to you, if you catch my drift, that is why I simply compared Brady and Favre with the only other great QB of this generation

How do you know what it would mean to me? You asked us the question and i did the same with you.

[mavskidd02]

That is such BS. Does Cal Ripken Jr hold the All time record for errors? No ........

I agree it is such bull shit.

So if that's the case, why is he not praised for throwing for miles of yards, and more TDs than anyone else who has ever stepped foot on the field?

That is the goal of the game, no? Get yards, score points. No one does it better than Favre if you want to look at "records"

[wayne1218]

I agree it is such bull shit.

So if that's the case, why is he not praised for throwing for miles of yards, and more TDs than anyone else who has ever stepped foot on the field?

That is the goal of the game, no? Get yards, score points. No one does it better than Favre if you want to look at "records"

HE IS!!!!!!!!

Why do you think people have him rated so highly???????????

[mavskidd02]

How do you know what it would mean to me? You asked us the question and i did the same with you.

Wayne if I told you who the greatest QB of "all time" was, you would say it doesn't mean shit, because I haven't seen half the guys you've seen play.

So, yes, I do know what it would mean to you.