Trading ARod in fantasy baseball

[BillMill71]

I am in a Roto 5X5 league where I have Arod. Of course offers have come flying in, most suck. But here is one that I thought interesting:

I give:

ARod/Youkilis/A Reyes (stl)


I get:

J Mourneau/A Ramirez/E Bedard

Thoughts?

[kbsooner21]

No deal

[TheRook]

Wait till September and then do it.

























but seriously folks....


It's intriguing....if Rameriez was doing anything right now, I'd probably do it. Maybe counter and get a better starting pitcher?? If he wants GayRod that bad, he'll have to give a little more

[kbsooner21]

but seriously folks....


It's intriguing....if Rameriez was doing anything right now, I'd probably do it. Maybe counter and get a better starting pitcher?? If he wants GayRod that bad, he'll have to give a little more

I agree. I'm going to have to get a better pitcher than Bedard to give up Gay Rod definitely

[10DimeBry]

i would say NO deal. gay-rod is in a walk year of his contract. he will put up monster #'s all year long.

[TheRook]

i would say NO deal. gay-rod is in a walk year of his contract. he will put up monster #'s all year long until the playoffs or in any 9th inning of a clutch situation. Then it's choke city.

Good call Ass

[10DimeBry]

Good call Ass

LMAO thats so freakin true

[BillMill71]

Thanks for the feedback

What about

I give:

ARod/Youkilis/A Reyes (stl)


I get:

J Mourneau/A Ramirez/HAMELS



I also received another offer of

ARod/Youkilis/K Wells

for

Smoltz/Hafner/E Byrnes

[kbsooner21]

I'll be honest. I flat out wouldn't trade A-Rod

[BettorsChat]

i would say NO deal. gay-rod is in a walk year of his contract. he will put up monster #'s all year long.

He puts up monster #'s every year that's why he's a future HOF

[10DimeBry]

He puts up monster #'s every year that's why he's a future HOF

i agree but this year will be his best ever. WATCH!!!

[BettorsChat]

i agree but this year will be his best ever. WATCH!!!

Most players perform their best when a contract is expiring for some reason.

[RDOG55]

Most players perform their best when a contract is expiring for some reason.

Its to make more money the next year...

[gizmo]

My Opinion

I also think A-rod will put up huge #'s,but the trade I would make is.

A-rod/Youkilis/A.Reyes for

Smoltz/Hafner/Byrnes

Smoltz is better than Reyes and Wells you get to keep,who I also think will have a good year.

Hafner will help make up the difference of Youkilis and you get the stolen bases back with Byrnes.

GIZ