College QB ranking?

[Gookis]

Bored at work, so....assume all these guys were available in the draft, what order do you rank them?:

Brady Quinn (ND)
Brian Brohm (I think it is Brian, Louisville)
Jamarcus Russell (LSU)
Drew Stanton (Mich St.)
Troy Smith (OSU)

My order:
Russell
Brohm
Stanton
Smith
Quinn

[hokie99]

1. Russell
2. Troy Smith
3. Brohm
4. Stanton
5. Quinn. And he's distant...

Russell has the whole Culpepper thing going and wins big games. Smith wins games and he's a great talent. Brohm has all the tools to be a very good NFL QB.

Stanton and Quinn are way down IMO. Neither wins big games and I think both would be below average in the NFL based on decision making and their arms. They'd be 'system' guys at best...

But of course the Raiders will probably draft Quinn and set themselves back another 10 years...

[longnex]

My order:
Russell
Brohm
Stanton
Smith
Quinn


You forgot Brennan from Hawaii.

[kbsooner21]

I think you all are throwing Quinn out cause of 1 bad performance. He's definitely played for the most complex offense out there under Weis, so he's got a notch above all the others in that standpoint.

Russell
Quinn
Brohm
Smith
Stanton