is Mc Nabb

[10DimeBry]

McFraud is an average QB in the league @ best.

[frankb03]

big mike the conf. doesnt have any great qbs left or teams,
top qbs in past years been warner, delhome for about 3 years combined and favre on the downhill, i'll give you culpepper for 2 years maybe and vick for 1 but who else is out there?
no brady, manning, green, even gannon for that one mvp year out there.

IMO, McNabb is a good QB. I highly doubt he'll become a Hall of Fame QB.

[jhedrick]

McNabb is a very good QB. He was the only weapon on the team last night and was the only play maker the Eagles had.

Will the people who claim McNabb / Vick / Manning are "over-rated" please define their meaning of this word? Who the hell are you comparing these players too???