Michael Vick

[Hoosier Daddy]

I know the guy is talented, but to me, he is BY FAR the most over-rated player in the NFL, and in the lower-echelon of NFL QBs. He has guys wide open and can't make the easy pass, and has no touch on his passes....everything is a rocket.

[LVJimmy]

I've said this since he's been in the league. Someone on here had the nerve to say he is better than McNabb in a recent thread.

[griffey_mojo]

I think Vick is a little over-rated too but.....

1. Atlanta wins games
2. He puts butts in the seats
3. He is the reason for a lot of revenue generated.

[Hoosier Daddy]

I've said this since he's been in the league. Someone on here had the nerve to say he is better than McNabb in a recent thread.

at what.....bowling?

That's comical. There are at least 8 QBs, and probably more than that I'd rather have.

[musclemann]

What?

I've said this since he's been in the league. Someone on here had the nerve to say he is better than McNabb in a recent thread.

LETS SEE HE SITS OUT FOR THE YEAR, THE FALCONS WIN 4 GAMES.HE PLAYS A WHOLE SEASON THE FALCONS GO TO THE NFL CHAMPIONSHIP. YEA HE SUCKS! THE MOST OVERATED PLAYER IN THE NFL IS BRIAN URLACHER.

[LVJimmy]

LETS SEE HE SITS OUT FOR THE YEAR, THE FALCONS WIN 4 GAMES.HE PLAYS A WHOLE SEASON THE FALCONS GO TO THE NFL CHAMPIONSHIP. YEA HE SUCKS! THE MOST OVERATED PLAYER IN THE NFL IS BRIAN URLACHER.

Sucks no, better than McNabb, HELL NO...he is a RB playing QB...simply put, Atlanta will NEVER win a SB with him at QB. The guy can't throw the ball worth a shit even to wide open receivers.

[Hoosier Daddy]

LETS SEE HE SITS OUT FOR THE YEAR, THE FALCONS WIN 4 GAMES.HE PLAYS A WHOLE SEASON THE FALCONS GO TO THE NFL CHAMPIONSHIP. YEA HE SUCKS! THE MOST OVERATED PLAYER IN THE NFL IS BRIAN URLACHER.

Nobody said he sucks.....but he certainly isn't an elite QB. As for Urlacher, look at the difference in the Bears D when he's out compared to when he's in there. Night and day. With Urlacher and everyone else healthy, they're a top 5 defense. He also leads all LB's in sacks this year, and doesn't blitz every play.

[Spearit]

His QB rating has to be the lowest for a winning team and his 3 TDs were nothing more than hogging the ball. He has had two bad games and still wins. Thank you Mr. Vick Thanx for the win.

[cpickard43]

Over rated or not- Vick is fun to watch.

[BorgataRob]

I think Vick is a little over-rated too but.....

1. Atlanta wins games
2. He puts butts in the seats
3. He is the reason for a lot of revenue generated.

Your right on the $$$ Grif.Vick is a sandlot QB but the fans love him! Why do you think Va tech is on thurs night football twice in a row.People want to see Marcus as well.Atlanta has strong fever in the dome more so than they ever had with Chris Chandler!

[cpickard43]

Vick is only 25 years old. I will go out on a limb and say he will win a super bowl. If Atlanta offered Vick for Mcnabb -Phili would take that trade

[Tony Vegas]

Great player not a great QB. All they do is win with him.

[BigMike]

Vick is only 25 years old. I will go out on a limb and say he will win a super bowl. If Atlanta offered Vick for Mcnabb -Phili would take that trade

BWAHHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAAH

You have to be fucking joking

[jhedrick]

Here are two other points that have gone unnoticed.
1. Atlanta leads the league in rushing 2 years in a row. Thats all bcse of Vick. You can take the oh so important QB Rating, I'll take the rushing yards and the wins!!!

2. How is it a knock that Vick is RB playing QB??? If your damn RB could do what Vick does then it would sit down every QB short of Peyton, Brady and McNabb.

extra point. QB like Point Guards, and Goalies are judged on winning games, so go ahead and make yourself seem even more igorant by saying #7 is "over-rated!"
...you go ahead and take Jeff Geroge with his rocket arm and deftly soft touch on the ball and I'll take that RB who throws the ball everyonce in a while and in the mean time just wins games...

[10DimeBry]

who are you guys talkin about?? doesnt the guy go by this name: www.ronmexico.com