Eagles!!!!!!!!!!

[bwade210]

.....who said anything about McNabb stinking or taking Tim Ratay over him.....I simply said he was "one of the most overrated players in the N.F.L", and it's true.

[frankb03]

I think Donovan McNabb is one of the most overrated players in the NFL.

I agree. McNabb is overrated. There's about 10 NFL QBs that if they played in Philly for Reid and with the Eagles D would have done better than McNabb has done. They went to the Super Bowl last season because the NFC was very weak.

McNabb at best is an above average QB

[10DimeBry]

Sorry for the useless thread, but wahoo!!! THE EAGELS!!!!

WOOOOOOOO fuck the eagles they suck they aint winning shit. If SD showed up 1st have they win by 20.

[10DimeBry]

You're right what was I thinking? McNabb stinks, I would take Tim Rattay over him

McFraud is overrated. I'd take trent dilfer over McFraud. Atleast Dilfer has a SB ring.

[bwade210]

I said that earlier and you would have thought McNabb's soup tossing mom caught wind of it.....face it Philadelphian's "McNabb is overrated!"

[BorgataRob]

You're right what was I thinking? McNabb stinks, I would take Tim Rattay over him

Mike don't waste your time with this guy. Mcnabb carried this team on his back before we ever had Owens. He is really hurt right now and should not be playing but Andy Ried insists on this and it is hurting this team right now.For someone to come out with this overrated bullshit is just not aware of the FACTS!!!!

[cpickard43]

Where is Rush Limbough when you need him?

[bwade210]

[QUOTE=BorgataRob]Mike don't waste your time with this guy. Mcnabb carried this team on his back before we ever had Owens. He is really hurt right now and should not be playing but Andy Ried insists on this and it is hurting this team right now.For someone to come out with this overrated bullshit is just not aware of the FACTS!!!![/QUOTE


Again...new guy same argument. What are the facts? Eagles have "one of the best offenses in the NFL"....yet McNabb STRUGGLES to get them into the end zone game after game!

[BorgataRob]

THIS SEASON HE HAS TROUBLE BUT HE IS HURT!!!! DID HE HAVE THIS TROUBLE LAST SEASON?? NO HE DID NOT! YOUR FUCKING CRAZY IF YOUR GONNA MAKE THAT STATEMENT BASED ON 6 games or even 7 if you COUNT THE BOWL!YOU no nothing about the GAME YOU ARE JUST LETTING YOUR HATRED FOR THE EAGLES CLOUD YOUR JUDGEMENT! MCNABB SHOULD BE ON THE I FUCKING R RIGHT NOW!!!!!

[bwade210]

first of all it's "you know nothing" not "you no nothing" and second of all those 6 or 7 games you speak of all the whole fucking season. Fine...he is one of the most overrated players in the NFL this season. Most in Philadelphia would be saying the same if the Eagle Defense (which by the way had to keep them in the game all day long) would not have blocked that field goal!

[Packerskoach]

If Mcnabb is overrated then we can all agree that Peyton Manning is just as overrated... IF you consider Mcnabb an under acheiving QB based on his performance for the past few weeks then the same argument goes for Manning. He has the best offensive arsenal (MUCH BETTER THAN PHILLYs) and they struggled to put points on the board... i.e. against cleveland, san fran (skins put up 52 on them), Jacksonville... I personally think Mcnabb and Manning are placed in the top 5 qbs in the league. Youre crazy if you think Mcnabb is overrated.

[dave T]

4 straigth NFC Championship trips and one to the SB...that says it all.

dt

[bwade210]

If Mcnabb is overrated then we can all agree that Peyton Manning is just as overrated... IF you consider Mcnabb an under acheiving QB based on his performance for the past few weeks then the same argument goes for Manning. He has the best offensive arsenal (MUCH BETTER THAN PHILLYs) and they struggled to put points on the board... i.e. against cleveland, san fran (skins put up 52 on them), Jacksonville... I personally think Mcnabb and Manning are placed in the top 5 qbs in the league. Youre crazy if you think Mcnabb is overrated.

Well, I think Manning is a good QB. I have never seen a QB be able to control his team so well, especially at the line. He can audible so well, I would love to have him on my favorite team. But I also agree that he has not won anything yet so he could go down in some peoples opinions as overrated. But McNabb, that motherfucker is totally overrated. I dont care about 4 NFC championships and one Super Bowl appearance and I'm sure that Eagle fans don't either. It's about winning the Super Bowl and if you dont do that then your just average. That's the difference between Jim Kelly and Tom Brady!

[Croughn]

Well, I think Manning is a good QB. I have never seen a QB be able to control his team so well, especially at the line. He can audible so well, I would love to have him on my favorite team. But I also agree that he has not won anything yet so he could go down in some peoples opinions as overrated. But McNabb, that motherfucker is totally overrated. I dont care about 4 NFC championships and one Super Bowl appearance and I'm sure that Eagle fans don't either. It's about winning the Super Bowl and if you dont do that then your just average. That's the difference between Jim Kelly and Tom Brady!

Marino did'nt win a ring...was he overrated and just average?? thats a weak argument

[mark30]

You guys are crazy. McNabb is not overated. At worst he is the 3rd best QB in the league. He has won more games the last 6 years than any other QB. He nevers throws a lot of INTS. He completion % has gone up every year.
Frank if you think McNabb is only an average QB, than you must think all the QB's in the NFL suck.