NFL - Take 2: Saints vs. Rams
Tuesday, our scouts filed their advance advance scouting report on this
week's matchup between the Saints and Rams. Now they're back with a second
look.With RB Deuce McAllister out, the once-balanced Saints' offense will
become much more one-dimensional. QB Aaron Brooks is now under a lot more
pressure to perform than he was with McAllister in the lineup, and he's
not going to have the advantage of throwing against vulnerable defenses
that he frequently had on first and second downs when opponents were
overloading to stop the run.
The good news is that Brooks played well last week when McAllister went
down. With 34 attempts, he seemed to get into more of a rhythm as a passer
and was as accurate as we have seen from him on film in a long time. If
you take a "cup half full" approach, there is a thought process that maybe
Brooks will be a more consistent passer and performer with more attempts
and more pressure on him to be "the guy."
However, if you take the "cup half empty" approach, Brooks will have a
much more difficult time going up against a Rams defense that has had an
entire week to prepare for the McAllister-less offense. With that in mind,
there's no question that Rams defensive coordinator Larry Marmie will turn
up the heat this week. He knows that Brooks is still struggling with a
quadriceps strain that has limited his mobility. He also knows that the
Saints lack a home-run hitting back to counter with on draws and screens
if the Rams are overly aggressive with their blitz package. Look for St.
Louis to attack from all different angles. The Rams have great speed at
outside linebacker with Pisa Tinoisamoa and Brandon Chillar, and they also
have a versatile safety in Adam Archuleta who they can turn loose as a
pass rusher at any time.
SteckerWhen the Saints do run the football, Aaron Stecker will handle most
of the carries and will get some help from Ki-Jana Carter, who was
re-signed after being cut just a week ago. The good news is that Stecker
is a capable receiver with decent quickness with the ball in his hands. He
also is a fine blocker for his size. However, Stecker simply won't provide
the same speed, cutback ability, power or acceleration that McAllister
offers this offense when he is healthy. Instead of relying on McAllister
to provide the big plays on the ground or as a short-yardage receiver who
can break a long run after the catch, the Saints will use Stecker to
maintain some balance but will have to count on their receivers to step up
as the playmakers.
Unlike most defenses, the Rams will still play lots of zone coverage
behind the blitz. If you study them on film you see that they mix in a
several different variations of zone coverage and also play some "combo"
packages. The goal is to force Brooks into making a quick decision as the
pocket collapses around him and get him to throw to the wrong receiver
because he made a hasty read against a confusing coverage look.
Last week, the Rams couldn't be as aggressive because of Michael Vick's
running ability. Brooks can run a little bit but, as mentioned, he's not a
full strength and the team is really trying to get him to avoid running as
much as possible because it can't afford him to miss significant time with
a pulled muscle. With that in mind, the Rams should be in much better
shape to pressure the quarterback this week than they were last week
against Vick, who simply would take off and run (12 times for 109 yards)
if he didn't like what he saw.
DishmanAs much as fans and the media like to point the finger at QB Marc
Bulger concerning the Rams' offensive woes, the film shows that the
problems start up front. From a statistical standpoint, Bulger was sacked
five times last week and the Rams rushed for just 30 total yards on 15
carries. From an execution standpoint, this unit is clearly uncomfortable
with one another in terms of communication and assignments, and LOG Chris
Dishman and ROT Grant Williams are significant downgrades from the
starters they are replacing, Dave Wohlabaugh and Kyle Turley,
respectively. Essentially, with McCollum moving from left guard to center,
the unit has just two members (LOT Orlando Pace and ROG Adam Timmerman) in
the same starting positions they were in at the end of 2003, when the
Rams' offensive line was among the best in the league in the second half
of the season.
Saints defensive coordinator Rick Venturi isn't crazy. He's not going to
leave CBs Ashley Ambrose and Fred Thomas on islands against WRs Torry Holt
and Isaac Bruce. However, because of the problems that the Rams are having
in pass protection, expect to see a more aggressive approach than we're
used to seeing against the Rams' offense. For starters, the Saints will
still give their cornerbacks safety help deep, but they might cheat their
safeties up a little bit and ask Ambrose and Thomas to utilize more press
technique at the line of scrimmage in order to stall the Rams' receivers
long enough to give the Saints a chance to get to Bulger. Furthermore, the
Saints' defense is a unit that blitzes a whole lot already, and with an
opportunity to capitalize on the communication errors that the Rams' line
is experiencing, they might turn up the heat.
In order to counter the pass rush pressure the Saints will try to
establish early on, don't be surprised to see RB Marshall Faulk used on
several screens, draws and flairs. Teams have had success with those plays
against the Saints' defense so far this season because they are pass-rush
neutralizers. By allowing the Saints' attacking defensive line and
blitzing linebackers and/or safeties get upfield on screens draws and
dump-off type routes, it provides Faulk the opportunity to get the ball in
the underneath zone that is vacated by the blitz, which potentially should
allow him to work his magic in space. In short, instead of trying to force
things downfield to Bruce and Holt, the Rams need to be smart and patient,
especially early on in order to get the Saints to cool off on some of
their blitz packages.
Special Teams
There isn't a glaring difference, but the edge on special teams would have
to go to New Orleans in this game. For starters, Jeff Wilkins remains one
of the elite place-kickers in the league, but John Carney has been just as
solid this season, connecting on all three of his attempts. The Saints
have a small edge in the punting department, as Mitch Berger clearly has
the stronger leg at this point compared to the Rams' Sean Landeta, but
with the game being played indoors that won't be as big of an impact,
especially considering Landeta's terrific accuracy on directional punts.
The real discrepancy comes in the return game. The Rams haven't made any
mistakes in that area but RB Steven Jackson has not been overly impressive
early on and is averaging just 19.8 yards per kickoff return. PR Shaun
McDonald is averaging just 3.7 per punt return. Michael Lewis, who
averages 9.7 yards per punt return and 26.1 yards per kickoff return,
provides an element of explosiveness that could give the Saints a big
advantage in this facet of the game.
Matchups
St. Louis LOT Orlando Pace vs. New Orleans RDE Will Smith.
St. Louis RB Marshall Faulk vs. New Orleans MLB Courtney Watson.
St. Louis WR Torry Holt vs. New Orleans RDC Fred Thomas.
New Orleans QB Aaron Brooks vs. St. Louis FS Aeneas Williams.
New Orleans ROT Victor Riley vs. St. Louis LDE Leonard Little.
Prediction: Rams 27, Saints 23
Tuesday, our scouts filed their advance advance scouting report on this
week's matchup between the Saints and Rams. Now they're back with a second
look.With RB Deuce McAllister out, the once-balanced Saints' offense will
become much more one-dimensional. QB Aaron Brooks is now under a lot more
pressure to perform than he was with McAllister in the lineup, and he's
not going to have the advantage of throwing against vulnerable defenses
that he frequently had on first and second downs when opponents were
overloading to stop the run.
The good news is that Brooks played well last week when McAllister went
down. With 34 attempts, he seemed to get into more of a rhythm as a passer
and was as accurate as we have seen from him on film in a long time. If
you take a "cup half full" approach, there is a thought process that maybe
Brooks will be a more consistent passer and performer with more attempts
and more pressure on him to be "the guy."
However, if you take the "cup half empty" approach, Brooks will have a
much more difficult time going up against a Rams defense that has had an
entire week to prepare for the McAllister-less offense. With that in mind,
there's no question that Rams defensive coordinator Larry Marmie will turn
up the heat this week. He knows that Brooks is still struggling with a
quadriceps strain that has limited his mobility. He also knows that the
Saints lack a home-run hitting back to counter with on draws and screens
if the Rams are overly aggressive with their blitz package. Look for St.
Louis to attack from all different angles. The Rams have great speed at
outside linebacker with Pisa Tinoisamoa and Brandon Chillar, and they also
have a versatile safety in Adam Archuleta who they can turn loose as a
pass rusher at any time.
SteckerWhen the Saints do run the football, Aaron Stecker will handle most
of the carries and will get some help from Ki-Jana Carter, who was
re-signed after being cut just a week ago. The good news is that Stecker
is a capable receiver with decent quickness with the ball in his hands. He
also is a fine blocker for his size. However, Stecker simply won't provide
the same speed, cutback ability, power or acceleration that McAllister
offers this offense when he is healthy. Instead of relying on McAllister
to provide the big plays on the ground or as a short-yardage receiver who
can break a long run after the catch, the Saints will use Stecker to
maintain some balance but will have to count on their receivers to step up
as the playmakers.
Unlike most defenses, the Rams will still play lots of zone coverage
behind the blitz. If you study them on film you see that they mix in a
several different variations of zone coverage and also play some "combo"
packages. The goal is to force Brooks into making a quick decision as the
pocket collapses around him and get him to throw to the wrong receiver
because he made a hasty read against a confusing coverage look.
Last week, the Rams couldn't be as aggressive because of Michael Vick's
running ability. Brooks can run a little bit but, as mentioned, he's not a
full strength and the team is really trying to get him to avoid running as
much as possible because it can't afford him to miss significant time with
a pulled muscle. With that in mind, the Rams should be in much better
shape to pressure the quarterback this week than they were last week
against Vick, who simply would take off and run (12 times for 109 yards)
if he didn't like what he saw.
DishmanAs much as fans and the media like to point the finger at QB Marc
Bulger concerning the Rams' offensive woes, the film shows that the
problems start up front. From a statistical standpoint, Bulger was sacked
five times last week and the Rams rushed for just 30 total yards on 15
carries. From an execution standpoint, this unit is clearly uncomfortable
with one another in terms of communication and assignments, and LOG Chris
Dishman and ROT Grant Williams are significant downgrades from the
starters they are replacing, Dave Wohlabaugh and Kyle Turley,
respectively. Essentially, with McCollum moving from left guard to center,
the unit has just two members (LOT Orlando Pace and ROG Adam Timmerman) in
the same starting positions they were in at the end of 2003, when the
Rams' offensive line was among the best in the league in the second half
of the season.
Saints defensive coordinator Rick Venturi isn't crazy. He's not going to
leave CBs Ashley Ambrose and Fred Thomas on islands against WRs Torry Holt
and Isaac Bruce. However, because of the problems that the Rams are having
in pass protection, expect to see a more aggressive approach than we're
used to seeing against the Rams' offense. For starters, the Saints will
still give their cornerbacks safety help deep, but they might cheat their
safeties up a little bit and ask Ambrose and Thomas to utilize more press
technique at the line of scrimmage in order to stall the Rams' receivers
long enough to give the Saints a chance to get to Bulger. Furthermore, the
Saints' defense is a unit that blitzes a whole lot already, and with an
opportunity to capitalize on the communication errors that the Rams' line
is experiencing, they might turn up the heat.
In order to counter the pass rush pressure the Saints will try to
establish early on, don't be surprised to see RB Marshall Faulk used on
several screens, draws and flairs. Teams have had success with those plays
against the Saints' defense so far this season because they are pass-rush
neutralizers. By allowing the Saints' attacking defensive line and
blitzing linebackers and/or safeties get upfield on screens draws and
dump-off type routes, it provides Faulk the opportunity to get the ball in
the underneath zone that is vacated by the blitz, which potentially should
allow him to work his magic in space. In short, instead of trying to force
things downfield to Bruce and Holt, the Rams need to be smart and patient,
especially early on in order to get the Saints to cool off on some of
their blitz packages.
Special Teams
There isn't a glaring difference, but the edge on special teams would have
to go to New Orleans in this game. For starters, Jeff Wilkins remains one
of the elite place-kickers in the league, but John Carney has been just as
solid this season, connecting on all three of his attempts. The Saints
have a small edge in the punting department, as Mitch Berger clearly has
the stronger leg at this point compared to the Rams' Sean Landeta, but
with the game being played indoors that won't be as big of an impact,
especially considering Landeta's terrific accuracy on directional punts.
The real discrepancy comes in the return game. The Rams haven't made any
mistakes in that area but RB Steven Jackson has not been overly impressive
early on and is averaging just 19.8 yards per kickoff return. PR Shaun
McDonald is averaging just 3.7 per punt return. Michael Lewis, who
averages 9.7 yards per punt return and 26.1 yards per kickoff return,
provides an element of explosiveness that could give the Saints a big
advantage in this facet of the game.
Matchups
St. Louis LOT Orlando Pace vs. New Orleans RDE Will Smith.
St. Louis RB Marshall Faulk vs. New Orleans MLB Courtney Watson.
St. Louis WR Torry Holt vs. New Orleans RDC Fred Thomas.
New Orleans QB Aaron Brooks vs. St. Louis FS Aeneas Williams.
New Orleans ROT Victor Riley vs. St. Louis LDE Leonard Little.
Prediction: Rams 27, Saints 23
Comment