Our scouts take a second look at this week's matchup between the 49ers and Saints.
Although San Francisco QB Ken Dorsey will be making his first NFL start
this weekend, it's important to note that he took the majority of his
snaps with the first-team during mini-camps. With Tim Rattay recovering
from offseason groin surgery, Dorsey was able to gain some valuable
experience. Dorsey's knowledge and command of the 49ers' offense may not
be as limited as we first thought.
The biggest surprise from San Francisco's game against the Falcons was the
play of TE Eric Johnson, who caught the ball eight times for 86 yards and
a score. Johnson missed all of last season with a broken collarbone, but
the former college wideout looked great in his 2004 debut and should play
a major role in San Francisco's passing game.
49ers' rookie DC Shawntae Spencer will step into the starting lineup for
Mike Rumph, but his inexperience could be a problem working against the
Saints' talented trio of receivers. Expect to see some combination
coverages from the 49ers, as they'll try to protect Spencer.
New Orleans WR Joe Horn has had 100-yard receiving games in three of his
past five games against the 49ers. He should have little trouble
approaching the century mark once again, as he'll be working against San
Francisco's battered secondary. With Rumph out (groin) and safeties Tony
Parrish, Dwaine Carpenter and Ronnie Heard hampered by leg injuries, the
49ers will have a tough time keeping Horn under wraps.
RDE Andre Carter's back is bothering him, and he may not play this
weekend. Officially, he is listed as doubtful, which means he probably
won't be available. If Carter pulls up lame, Josh Cooper, a rookie that
signed with the 49ers as a free agent, will be forced to step into the
starting lineup.
Without the speed of Carter off the edge, San Francisco may have trouble
generating a pass rush. Expect the 49ers to bring more blitzes this week
with OLB Julian Peterson leading the charge. Peterson is an exceptional
athlete and extremely versatile. Defensive coordinator Willy Robinson will
move Peterson around in an attempt to create matchup problems for the
Saints' protection.
The Saints were extremely sloppy last week, committing four turnovers,
drawing eight penalties and converting on just 3 of 14 third-down
attempts. They aren't good enough to consistently overcome those kinds of
mistakes, so they will have to play with much better discipline. The onus
will fall on New Orleans QB Aaron Brooks to play efficiently and avoid the
costly mistakes that have plagued this talented but inconsistent offense.
Last year Brooks led the league with 11 lost fumbles; he must secure the
football when in traffic because San Francisco will look to knock it loose
every opportunity it gets.
WR Cedric Wilson is coming off a strong game in which he caught seven
balls for 94 yards and a score. Despite his small stature (5-10, 183),
Wilson came up big on third downs, hauling in three passes for 40 yards
and a TD. With so many questions at receiver, Wilson must continue to
produce on third down.
The 49ers will line up in the 3-4-defense about a third of the time, as
the linebackers are clearly the strength of this defense. Robinson wants
to get as much speed on the field as possible. Robinson, however, hasn't
officially adopted a three-man front because of his undersized defensive
line. DT Anthony Adams can play over the nose, but, at 298 pounds, he
isn't a true anchor in the middle. While rookie Isaac Sopoaga (330 lbs.)
would be a better fit, he'll miss the remainder of the season with a back
injury. Robinson will only use the 3-4 as a change of pace in passing
situations.
Special Teams
The 49ers haven't had a punter ranked higher than 10th in the NFL in more
than 25 years, which explains why the team spent a sixth-round pick on PT
Andy Lee. Last week, in his professional debut, Lee averaged 40.8 yards on
six attempts, including a long of 55. Although its unlikely Lee will climb
into the top 10 this year, he does have a big upside and could put an end
to that streak as early as 2005. He needs to have a strong game and help
San Francisco win the battle of field position this week.
Matchups
New Orleans WR Joe Horn vs. San Francisco CB Shawntae Spencer.
San Francisco RB Kevan Barlow vs. New Orleans MLB Courtney Watson.
New Orleans TE Boo Williams vs. San Francisco SS Tony Parrish.
San Francisco TE Eric Johnson vs. New Orleans SS Jay Bellamy.
New Orleans QB Aaron Brooks vs. San Francisco OLB Julian Peterson
Prediction: Saints 23, 49ers 17
Although San Francisco QB Ken Dorsey will be making his first NFL start
this weekend, it's important to note that he took the majority of his
snaps with the first-team during mini-camps. With Tim Rattay recovering
from offseason groin surgery, Dorsey was able to gain some valuable
experience. Dorsey's knowledge and command of the 49ers' offense may not
be as limited as we first thought.
The biggest surprise from San Francisco's game against the Falcons was the
play of TE Eric Johnson, who caught the ball eight times for 86 yards and
a score. Johnson missed all of last season with a broken collarbone, but
the former college wideout looked great in his 2004 debut and should play
a major role in San Francisco's passing game.
49ers' rookie DC Shawntae Spencer will step into the starting lineup for
Mike Rumph, but his inexperience could be a problem working against the
Saints' talented trio of receivers. Expect to see some combination
coverages from the 49ers, as they'll try to protect Spencer.
New Orleans WR Joe Horn has had 100-yard receiving games in three of his
past five games against the 49ers. He should have little trouble
approaching the century mark once again, as he'll be working against San
Francisco's battered secondary. With Rumph out (groin) and safeties Tony
Parrish, Dwaine Carpenter and Ronnie Heard hampered by leg injuries, the
49ers will have a tough time keeping Horn under wraps.
RDE Andre Carter's back is bothering him, and he may not play this
weekend. Officially, he is listed as doubtful, which means he probably
won't be available. If Carter pulls up lame, Josh Cooper, a rookie that
signed with the 49ers as a free agent, will be forced to step into the
starting lineup.
Without the speed of Carter off the edge, San Francisco may have trouble
generating a pass rush. Expect the 49ers to bring more blitzes this week
with OLB Julian Peterson leading the charge. Peterson is an exceptional
athlete and extremely versatile. Defensive coordinator Willy Robinson will
move Peterson around in an attempt to create matchup problems for the
Saints' protection.
The Saints were extremely sloppy last week, committing four turnovers,
drawing eight penalties and converting on just 3 of 14 third-down
attempts. They aren't good enough to consistently overcome those kinds of
mistakes, so they will have to play with much better discipline. The onus
will fall on New Orleans QB Aaron Brooks to play efficiently and avoid the
costly mistakes that have plagued this talented but inconsistent offense.
Last year Brooks led the league with 11 lost fumbles; he must secure the
football when in traffic because San Francisco will look to knock it loose
every opportunity it gets.
WR Cedric Wilson is coming off a strong game in which he caught seven
balls for 94 yards and a score. Despite his small stature (5-10, 183),
Wilson came up big on third downs, hauling in three passes for 40 yards
and a TD. With so many questions at receiver, Wilson must continue to
produce on third down.
The 49ers will line up in the 3-4-defense about a third of the time, as
the linebackers are clearly the strength of this defense. Robinson wants
to get as much speed on the field as possible. Robinson, however, hasn't
officially adopted a three-man front because of his undersized defensive
line. DT Anthony Adams can play over the nose, but, at 298 pounds, he
isn't a true anchor in the middle. While rookie Isaac Sopoaga (330 lbs.)
would be a better fit, he'll miss the remainder of the season with a back
injury. Robinson will only use the 3-4 as a change of pace in passing
situations.
Special Teams
The 49ers haven't had a punter ranked higher than 10th in the NFL in more
than 25 years, which explains why the team spent a sixth-round pick on PT
Andy Lee. Last week, in his professional debut, Lee averaged 40.8 yards on
six attempts, including a long of 55. Although its unlikely Lee will climb
into the top 10 this year, he does have a big upside and could put an end
to that streak as early as 2005. He needs to have a strong game and help
San Francisco win the battle of field position this week.
Matchups
New Orleans WR Joe Horn vs. San Francisco CB Shawntae Spencer.
San Francisco RB Kevan Barlow vs. New Orleans MLB Courtney Watson.
New Orleans TE Boo Williams vs. San Francisco SS Tony Parrish.
San Francisco TE Eric Johnson vs. New Orleans SS Jay Bellamy.
New Orleans QB Aaron Brooks vs. San Francisco OLB Julian Peterson
Prediction: Saints 23, 49ers 17
Comment