NFC East: Midseason Report Cards
November 7, 2017
DALLAS COWBOYS
--PASSING OFFENSE: A - Dak Prescott is not having a sophomore slump. He is having an amazing encore season. He has 16 touchdown passes to just four interceptions and is on pace for more than 3,200 yards passing and 32 touchdowns. He has spread the ball around to 13 different receivers. Dez Bryant leads the way with 38 receptions for 439 yards and four touchdowns. But the Cowboys have five players with 19 or more catches, including Brice Butler and Cole Beasley with 19 and 22, respectively and three players with 30 or more, including Terrance Williams and TE Jason Witten with 30 and 35 respectively. Prescott has only been sacked 10 times on 261 attempts.
--RUSHING OFFENSE: A - Ezekiel Elliott is back producing like one of the top running backs in the league over the last four games and it has everything to do with the offensive line finally being solidified and developing some continuity after opening the season with two new starters, including a two-man rotation at left guard. La'el Collins is now comfortable at right tackle and Jonathan Cooper has taken control at left guard. Elliott has 783 yards to rank second in the league. He had three straight 100-yard games before being held to 93 yards on 27 carries against the Chiefs. He was still effective and dominant, and the running game remains key to everything the Cowboys do on offense and is the basis of the three-game winning streak.
--PASS DEFENSE: B - The Cowboys have the 17th best pass defense in the league, but interestingly enough they are second in the league with 27 sacks. That's huge for a Cowboys defense that has struggled to get to the quarterback in recent years and came into the season wondering who was going to rush the passer. DeMarcus Lawrence has been the leader with 10.5 sacks, ranking second in the league. David Irving has six sacks in four games.
--RUSH DEFENSE: C -- The Cowboys are 12th in the league in run defense, giving up 101.2 yards per game. But this is really about their failures against the run in the three losses to the Denver Broncos, Los Angeles Rams and Green Bay Packers where they allowed 100-yard rushers in all three outings after not allowing one in 16 games last season. It is of note that LB Sean Lee missed the Rams and Packers games and the Cowboys are a much better defense with Lee on the field. The Cowboys give up 164 rush yards per game without Lee and just 80.3 when he plays.
--SPECIAL TEAMS: B - Chris Jones has been a huge weapon, averaging 43.6 yards on 31 punts. Most important, he has had 18 punts downed inside the 20-yard line. Mike Nugent and Dan Bailey have made 11 of 12 field-goal attempts. Even safety Jeff Heath has made two of three extra points. The coverage teams have been excellent. However, the Cowboys have been disappointing on returns with rookie Ryan Switzer plagued by a fumble and poor decision-making.
--COACHING: A - Give head coach Jason Garrett credit for keeping the Cowboys focused and poised through the distractions of the Ezekiel Elliott roller coaster and the disappointment of a 2-3 start. The Cowboys have focused on controlling what they can control and have rebounded with three straight wins. More important, they are coming off their most complete game of the season and are looking like the playoff contender they were supposed to be.
N.Y. GIANTS
--PASSING OFFENSE: D-plus - While history might look back at Week 5, the week the Giants lost starting receivers Odell Beckham Jr. and Brandon Marshall for the season and slot receiver Sterling Shepard for two games, the passing offense wasn't exactly lighting things up before then. Part of that could be related to Beckham's preseason ankle injury that cost him the first game of the season and was one from which he never really appeared to fully recover, but quarterback Eli Manning's declining skill set combined with an offensive line whose pass protection was like a sieve didn't help matters either. Moving forward, Manning has to work with mostly receivers who initially weren't good enough to make the roster out of training camp, though the continued emergence of tight end Evan Engram in the passing game and the return of Shepard should help a little.
--RUSHING OFFENSE: C - It took an injury to starter Paul Perkins for the coaching staff to realize that the future of the running game, at least for the rest of this year, is with Orleans Darkwa and rookie Wayne Gallman and that they're much better off running to the right than to the left. With that said, Darkwa and Gallman's efforts haven't been enough to bring the Giants out of the bottom third of the league in team rushing; the 27th-ranked Giants offense is averaging 86.8 yards per game, partly due to the inconsistency on the field and partly due to a coaching staff that seems to look for any excuse to abandon the run and go to the passing game.
--PASS DEFENSE: F - The one-time vaunted New York Pass Defense -- NYPD for short -- has become a disorganized mess that has seen just about every member of that unit regress from last year. The Giants have now allowed 31 big passing plays this season of 20 or more yards, six of which have gone for 40 or more yards. Add to that a lethargic pass rush that so far has managed just 13 sacks through the first half of the season (tied for 27th in the NFL), and a linebacker/safety crew that has allowed opposing tight ends to score in every game this season, and it's fair to say the Giants' pass defense has seen better days.
--RUSH DEFENSE: C-minus - Gone are the days when the run defense held opponents to under 100 yards collectively in each game. Nowadays, teams are able to have success running against the Giants, a problem that is due in part to the injury-related absences of defensive end Olivier Vernon as well as the revolving door at linebacker. The biggest and most alarming trends have been the missed tackles and poor angles being taken at the second level and the inability to shed blocks. On the plus side, the play of interior linemen Damon Harrison and rookie Dalvin Tomlinson save this unit from a worse grade, but unfortunately two men can't do it all by their lonesome.
--SPECIAL TEAMS: F - The Giants' special teams have had just about everything that could go wrong for them happen: missed field goals, blocked kicks and punts, a punt returned for a touchdown and poor coverage all the way around. The Giants' special teams were an asset last year with helping the team win starting field position, but this year they've been a detriment that is likely heading for a major shakeup.
--COACHING: F - Head coach Ben McAdoo's sudden revelation to become a hard-line coach is an approach that should have been in place from Day 1 of his tenure. Instead, what the Giants now have, whether anyone wants to admit it or otherwise, is a brewing mutiny in which the players are rebelling in their own way against a coach who is suddenly the picture of discipline but who has yet to win anything of substance for the players to truly stand up and accept what McAdoo is trying to accomplish. While all teams have had to discipline players for infractions ranging from the minor to the major, most of those issues are kept in-house. McAdoo has now had to suspend two veteran members of his defense, he's disciplined Eli Apple at least twice, and running back Paul Perkins at least once. Combine that with McAdoo's struggle to communicate in the way he did last year with his team and his stubbornness to give up the play-calling until his hand was forced, and there is little hope things will get better. Meanwhile, defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo might be an affable man, but whatever tweaks he's made to his defense have turned the once mighty Giants into a pile of chumps. And the next time special teams does something that has a positive effect on the outcome of the game will be the first for the season; if anything, Tom Quinn's unit has been plagued by inconsistency.
PHILADELPHIA EAGLES
--PASSING OFFENSE: A - Carson Wentz's 16 rookie starts have paid off big-time for him and the Eagles. He's having an MVP season. He is fourth in passing and first in third-down passing. He leads the league in touchdown passes through nine games with 23. Tight end Zach Ertz and wide receiver Alshon Jeffery both have been extremely productive on third down and in the red zone.
--RUSHING OFFENSE: A-minus -- Through nine games, the Eagles are third in the league in rushing (136.8 yards per game) and fifth in rush average (4.3 yards per carry). They headed into the bye with an impressive 197-yard rushing effort against one of the league's top run defenses, the Broncos. The Eagles averaged 9.4 yards per carry on first down against the Broncos. The addition of Jay Ajayi, who had a 46-yard touchdown run against the Broncos, is going to make the Eagles tough to stop down the stretch.
--PASS DEFENSE: B-plus - After losing their best cornerback, Ronald Darby, to a dislocated ankle in Week 1, the Eagles started playing a lot of off-coverage with the focus being on not giving up the deep ball and limiting yards after the catch. They have one of the best tackling secondaries the Eagles have had in a long time. They have done an excellent job of shutting down teams on third down and are tied for sixth in sacks with 25.
--RUSH DEFENSE: A - The Eagles have held opponents to a league-best 66.4 yards per game on the ground. They've allowed just 16 runs of 10 yards or more in nine games, and 42 of their opponents' 166 carries have been for losses. Even with the loss of middle linebacker Jordan Hicks to a season-ending injury, they haven't skipped a beat.
--SPECIAL TEAMS: B-plus - They suffered a couple of big losses early on, losing K Caleb Sturgis and PR Darren Sproles to injuries. But Sturgis' replacement, Jake Elliott, has been outstanding, hitting five of six field-goal attempts from 50-plus yards. Sproles was one of the league's top return men, but his replacement, Kenjon Barner, has played well. For the most part, the Eagles' coverage teams have played well.
--COACHING: A-plus - Head coach Doug Pederson has proven to be an excellent play-caller. He and his staff have done an outstanding job of bringing along Carson Wentz in his second season. Defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz has been without his best cornerback (Ronald Darby) for eight games and has lost his middle linebacker (Jordan Hicks), but has managed to minimize their absences. He's blitzing more and has been very effective with it. His defense also has a league-high six interceptions on third down.
WASHINGTON REDSKINS
--PASSING OFFENSE: B - Continuity with wide receivers Josh Doctson and Terrelle Pryor has been an issue for quarterback Kirk Cousins. Injuries have struck tight end Jordan Reed and wide receiver Jamison Crowder. The offensive line is in shambles thanks to injuries and can't protect Cousins as it has in recent years. And yet Washington still ranks 10th in passing yards per game (244.4) and ninth in passing yards per play (6.74) with a passing game cobbled together with tight end Vernon Davis and running back Chris Thompson. Doctson is starting to emerge, too.
--RUSHING OFFENSE: C-minus - The Redskins haven't been able to get anything going on the ground. Rob Kelley has battled nagging injuries, they don't want to overuse Thompson and rookie Samaje Perine isn't ready to contribute yet and has struggled with fumbles. Washington ranks 22nd in rushing yards per game (98.7). The offensive line injuries haven't helped the run blocking.
--PASS DEFENSE: B - The Redskins rely heavily on cornerback Josh Norman and they still have a hole at strong safety. But corner Kendall Fuller has emerged (three interceptions) in his second year and Quinton Dunbar has impressed again after a rough second season at corner in 2016. That's helped make up for nagging injuries to Bashaud Breeland. Washington ranks 17th in passing yards allowed per game (226.4) and 18th in passing yards per play (6.18).
--RUSH DEFENSE: B - This group has slipped some after injuries to promising rookie Jonathan Allen (Lisfranc sprain) and second-year pro Matt Ioannidis (broken hand). But they are still right in the middle at No. 16 in rushing yards allowed per game (110.5).
--SPECIAL TEAMS: C - Injuries have hurt on special teams, too. Kicker Dustin Hopkins is on injured reserve and so many special teamers have had to play bigger roles on defense, it's taken a toll on the coverage units. Crowder has muffed three punts. Hopkins and new kicker Nick Rose have hit 13 of 16 field goals, but none beyond 48 yards.
--COACHING: B - The Redskins are still alive in the NFC playoff chase at 4-4 and just won a huge game in Seattle with nine starters missing, including four on the offensive line. That's a tribute to the coaching staff finding reserves who can play. Defensive coordinator Greg Manusky has found ways to generate pressure with a pass rush that still relies too much on Ryan Kerrigan - though Preston Smith has put a rough second year behind him. The offense is still trying to put the pieces together. If head coach Jay Gruden can get Reed, Crowder and left tackle Trent Williams healthy, the Redskins could take advantage of a weak schedule in December.
November 7, 2017
DALLAS COWBOYS
--PASSING OFFENSE: A - Dak Prescott is not having a sophomore slump. He is having an amazing encore season. He has 16 touchdown passes to just four interceptions and is on pace for more than 3,200 yards passing and 32 touchdowns. He has spread the ball around to 13 different receivers. Dez Bryant leads the way with 38 receptions for 439 yards and four touchdowns. But the Cowboys have five players with 19 or more catches, including Brice Butler and Cole Beasley with 19 and 22, respectively and three players with 30 or more, including Terrance Williams and TE Jason Witten with 30 and 35 respectively. Prescott has only been sacked 10 times on 261 attempts.
--RUSHING OFFENSE: A - Ezekiel Elliott is back producing like one of the top running backs in the league over the last four games and it has everything to do with the offensive line finally being solidified and developing some continuity after opening the season with two new starters, including a two-man rotation at left guard. La'el Collins is now comfortable at right tackle and Jonathan Cooper has taken control at left guard. Elliott has 783 yards to rank second in the league. He had three straight 100-yard games before being held to 93 yards on 27 carries against the Chiefs. He was still effective and dominant, and the running game remains key to everything the Cowboys do on offense and is the basis of the three-game winning streak.
--PASS DEFENSE: B - The Cowboys have the 17th best pass defense in the league, but interestingly enough they are second in the league with 27 sacks. That's huge for a Cowboys defense that has struggled to get to the quarterback in recent years and came into the season wondering who was going to rush the passer. DeMarcus Lawrence has been the leader with 10.5 sacks, ranking second in the league. David Irving has six sacks in four games.
--RUSH DEFENSE: C -- The Cowboys are 12th in the league in run defense, giving up 101.2 yards per game. But this is really about their failures against the run in the three losses to the Denver Broncos, Los Angeles Rams and Green Bay Packers where they allowed 100-yard rushers in all three outings after not allowing one in 16 games last season. It is of note that LB Sean Lee missed the Rams and Packers games and the Cowboys are a much better defense with Lee on the field. The Cowboys give up 164 rush yards per game without Lee and just 80.3 when he plays.
--SPECIAL TEAMS: B - Chris Jones has been a huge weapon, averaging 43.6 yards on 31 punts. Most important, he has had 18 punts downed inside the 20-yard line. Mike Nugent and Dan Bailey have made 11 of 12 field-goal attempts. Even safety Jeff Heath has made two of three extra points. The coverage teams have been excellent. However, the Cowboys have been disappointing on returns with rookie Ryan Switzer plagued by a fumble and poor decision-making.
--COACHING: A - Give head coach Jason Garrett credit for keeping the Cowboys focused and poised through the distractions of the Ezekiel Elliott roller coaster and the disappointment of a 2-3 start. The Cowboys have focused on controlling what they can control and have rebounded with three straight wins. More important, they are coming off their most complete game of the season and are looking like the playoff contender they were supposed to be.
N.Y. GIANTS
--PASSING OFFENSE: D-plus - While history might look back at Week 5, the week the Giants lost starting receivers Odell Beckham Jr. and Brandon Marshall for the season and slot receiver Sterling Shepard for two games, the passing offense wasn't exactly lighting things up before then. Part of that could be related to Beckham's preseason ankle injury that cost him the first game of the season and was one from which he never really appeared to fully recover, but quarterback Eli Manning's declining skill set combined with an offensive line whose pass protection was like a sieve didn't help matters either. Moving forward, Manning has to work with mostly receivers who initially weren't good enough to make the roster out of training camp, though the continued emergence of tight end Evan Engram in the passing game and the return of Shepard should help a little.
--RUSHING OFFENSE: C - It took an injury to starter Paul Perkins for the coaching staff to realize that the future of the running game, at least for the rest of this year, is with Orleans Darkwa and rookie Wayne Gallman and that they're much better off running to the right than to the left. With that said, Darkwa and Gallman's efforts haven't been enough to bring the Giants out of the bottom third of the league in team rushing; the 27th-ranked Giants offense is averaging 86.8 yards per game, partly due to the inconsistency on the field and partly due to a coaching staff that seems to look for any excuse to abandon the run and go to the passing game.
--PASS DEFENSE: F - The one-time vaunted New York Pass Defense -- NYPD for short -- has become a disorganized mess that has seen just about every member of that unit regress from last year. The Giants have now allowed 31 big passing plays this season of 20 or more yards, six of which have gone for 40 or more yards. Add to that a lethargic pass rush that so far has managed just 13 sacks through the first half of the season (tied for 27th in the NFL), and a linebacker/safety crew that has allowed opposing tight ends to score in every game this season, and it's fair to say the Giants' pass defense has seen better days.
--RUSH DEFENSE: C-minus - Gone are the days when the run defense held opponents to under 100 yards collectively in each game. Nowadays, teams are able to have success running against the Giants, a problem that is due in part to the injury-related absences of defensive end Olivier Vernon as well as the revolving door at linebacker. The biggest and most alarming trends have been the missed tackles and poor angles being taken at the second level and the inability to shed blocks. On the plus side, the play of interior linemen Damon Harrison and rookie Dalvin Tomlinson save this unit from a worse grade, but unfortunately two men can't do it all by their lonesome.
--SPECIAL TEAMS: F - The Giants' special teams have had just about everything that could go wrong for them happen: missed field goals, blocked kicks and punts, a punt returned for a touchdown and poor coverage all the way around. The Giants' special teams were an asset last year with helping the team win starting field position, but this year they've been a detriment that is likely heading for a major shakeup.
--COACHING: F - Head coach Ben McAdoo's sudden revelation to become a hard-line coach is an approach that should have been in place from Day 1 of his tenure. Instead, what the Giants now have, whether anyone wants to admit it or otherwise, is a brewing mutiny in which the players are rebelling in their own way against a coach who is suddenly the picture of discipline but who has yet to win anything of substance for the players to truly stand up and accept what McAdoo is trying to accomplish. While all teams have had to discipline players for infractions ranging from the minor to the major, most of those issues are kept in-house. McAdoo has now had to suspend two veteran members of his defense, he's disciplined Eli Apple at least twice, and running back Paul Perkins at least once. Combine that with McAdoo's struggle to communicate in the way he did last year with his team and his stubbornness to give up the play-calling until his hand was forced, and there is little hope things will get better. Meanwhile, defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo might be an affable man, but whatever tweaks he's made to his defense have turned the once mighty Giants into a pile of chumps. And the next time special teams does something that has a positive effect on the outcome of the game will be the first for the season; if anything, Tom Quinn's unit has been plagued by inconsistency.
PHILADELPHIA EAGLES
--PASSING OFFENSE: A - Carson Wentz's 16 rookie starts have paid off big-time for him and the Eagles. He's having an MVP season. He is fourth in passing and first in third-down passing. He leads the league in touchdown passes through nine games with 23. Tight end Zach Ertz and wide receiver Alshon Jeffery both have been extremely productive on third down and in the red zone.
--RUSHING OFFENSE: A-minus -- Through nine games, the Eagles are third in the league in rushing (136.8 yards per game) and fifth in rush average (4.3 yards per carry). They headed into the bye with an impressive 197-yard rushing effort against one of the league's top run defenses, the Broncos. The Eagles averaged 9.4 yards per carry on first down against the Broncos. The addition of Jay Ajayi, who had a 46-yard touchdown run against the Broncos, is going to make the Eagles tough to stop down the stretch.
--PASS DEFENSE: B-plus - After losing their best cornerback, Ronald Darby, to a dislocated ankle in Week 1, the Eagles started playing a lot of off-coverage with the focus being on not giving up the deep ball and limiting yards after the catch. They have one of the best tackling secondaries the Eagles have had in a long time. They have done an excellent job of shutting down teams on third down and are tied for sixth in sacks with 25.
--RUSH DEFENSE: A - The Eagles have held opponents to a league-best 66.4 yards per game on the ground. They've allowed just 16 runs of 10 yards or more in nine games, and 42 of their opponents' 166 carries have been for losses. Even with the loss of middle linebacker Jordan Hicks to a season-ending injury, they haven't skipped a beat.
--SPECIAL TEAMS: B-plus - They suffered a couple of big losses early on, losing K Caleb Sturgis and PR Darren Sproles to injuries. But Sturgis' replacement, Jake Elliott, has been outstanding, hitting five of six field-goal attempts from 50-plus yards. Sproles was one of the league's top return men, but his replacement, Kenjon Barner, has played well. For the most part, the Eagles' coverage teams have played well.
--COACHING: A-plus - Head coach Doug Pederson has proven to be an excellent play-caller. He and his staff have done an outstanding job of bringing along Carson Wentz in his second season. Defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz has been without his best cornerback (Ronald Darby) for eight games and has lost his middle linebacker (Jordan Hicks), but has managed to minimize their absences. He's blitzing more and has been very effective with it. His defense also has a league-high six interceptions on third down.
WASHINGTON REDSKINS
--PASSING OFFENSE: B - Continuity with wide receivers Josh Doctson and Terrelle Pryor has been an issue for quarterback Kirk Cousins. Injuries have struck tight end Jordan Reed and wide receiver Jamison Crowder. The offensive line is in shambles thanks to injuries and can't protect Cousins as it has in recent years. And yet Washington still ranks 10th in passing yards per game (244.4) and ninth in passing yards per play (6.74) with a passing game cobbled together with tight end Vernon Davis and running back Chris Thompson. Doctson is starting to emerge, too.
--RUSHING OFFENSE: C-minus - The Redskins haven't been able to get anything going on the ground. Rob Kelley has battled nagging injuries, they don't want to overuse Thompson and rookie Samaje Perine isn't ready to contribute yet and has struggled with fumbles. Washington ranks 22nd in rushing yards per game (98.7). The offensive line injuries haven't helped the run blocking.
--PASS DEFENSE: B - The Redskins rely heavily on cornerback Josh Norman and they still have a hole at strong safety. But corner Kendall Fuller has emerged (three interceptions) in his second year and Quinton Dunbar has impressed again after a rough second season at corner in 2016. That's helped make up for nagging injuries to Bashaud Breeland. Washington ranks 17th in passing yards allowed per game (226.4) and 18th in passing yards per play (6.18).
--RUSH DEFENSE: B - This group has slipped some after injuries to promising rookie Jonathan Allen (Lisfranc sprain) and second-year pro Matt Ioannidis (broken hand). But they are still right in the middle at No. 16 in rushing yards allowed per game (110.5).
--SPECIAL TEAMS: C - Injuries have hurt on special teams, too. Kicker Dustin Hopkins is on injured reserve and so many special teamers have had to play bigger roles on defense, it's taken a toll on the coverage units. Crowder has muffed three punts. Hopkins and new kicker Nick Rose have hit 13 of 16 field goals, but none beyond 48 yards.
--COACHING: B - The Redskins are still alive in the NFC playoff chase at 4-4 and just won a huge game in Seattle with nine starters missing, including four on the offensive line. That's a tribute to the coaching staff finding reserves who can play. Defensive coordinator Greg Manusky has found ways to generate pressure with a pass rush that still relies too much on Ryan Kerrigan - though Preston Smith has put a rough second year behind him. The offense is still trying to put the pieces together. If head coach Jay Gruden can get Reed, Crowder and left tackle Trent Williams healthy, the Redskins could take advantage of a weak schedule in December.
Comment