white or black......

[$$PIX]

McNabb rally does suck! No, the loss was not all his fault, but the guy is horrible. The Eagles won the first playoff game despite McNabb, not because of him!

just my opinion

[Shleprock]

I guess his all pro receivers really helped him out, or Phillys top offensive threat Westbrook was out was mcnabbs fault, or his offensive line could not handle Carolinas front four, or his playing with a torn rib cage had nothing to do with his performance. Stop blaming one man for a loss. Carolina just beat the snot out of the Eagles IT is called a TEAM .

[Art]

The Philly receivers were not that bad - media excuses for McNabb's lame performance.

[$$PIX]

You write well, but need to learn to read! I did not say it was his fault that the Eagles lost. I said the guy sucks! If I (not you) were choosing the top ten QB's in the NFL to play on my team, he would not be one of them. Not because he is black, race has nothing to do with my selections, but because he is NOT GOOD!

[maxell]

It's funny that a guy deemed "not that good" rallied his team to the NFC championship game. Nevermind that they were left for dead after game 3 of the season and he willed them into the championship game. "Not that good" set arushing record for quarterbacks in his previous playoff game. He did what he did with an offense that really was "not that good" to begin with. Oh yes forget the numerous dropped passes or the fact that Pinkston decides to change his slant route to an out and up inside the Carolina 15 resulting in an interception and basically taking the wind out of the Eagles' sails.

Funny how there is not a mention of the other loser in yesterday's championship games. Peyton Manning, what can you say, DRIVE FOR SHOW BUT CAN'T PUTT FOR DOUGH. A classic example of a choker if there ever was one. He had all the weapons at his disposal that "not that good" wished he had, but interception after interception killed their chances. New England gave them every opportunity to get back in the game by kicking field goal after field goal. Manning's on his way to the Hall of Fame, now lets see if he can win something for a change.

[$$PIX]

Maxwell????

Maxwell,

If you started an NFL team tomorrow, would you choose McNabb or Manning as your QB? Assuming they were your only two choices.

[frankb03]

Originally posted by Art
The Philly receivers were not that bad - media excuses for McNabb's lame performance.

Media excuses for McNabb's mediocre talent as a QB. He would have made a better RB or receiver.

[Shleprock]

Yeah a 250LB receiver or running back that runs a 4.7 40 get a clue.

[poboy]

mcnabb may be whatever but pinkstonand trash had one catch for 9 yards between them if that is considered not bad then my god what is bad