I’ve identified 11 coaching changes at major programs and we’re ready to rank ‘em and discuss at length, so here we go…
#1: Brian Kelly (Notre Dame) -- The Irish struck out in trying to hire Urban Meyer several years ago, settling instead for Charlie Weis. As we know, that didn’t go so well. This time around, Notre Dame got it right, plucking the hottest coach on the market away from Cincinnati. Eighteen months ago, I wrote that “Tennessee will regret not hiring Brian Kelly instead of Lane Kiffin for decades.” I thoroughly stand by that remark. Kelly has done an outstanding job in prior tenures at Central Michigan and Cincinnati, where he led the Bearcats to an unbeaten regular season in 2009. The only blemish on his resume is so-so recruiting classes the last few years, but now he has a great product in Notre Dame football to sell.
#2: Tommy Tuberville (Texas Tech) -- I’m still floored that Tuberville and former Tennessee head coach Phil Fulmer didn’t generate more interest from other schools in their coaching searches. When the Mike Leach fiasco went down, however, Tuberville was wisely hired by the Red Raiders. The dude just knows how to coach. He won at Ole Miss and won big at Auburn, including a 13-0 record in 2004. Tuberville has beaten Urban Meyer in both head-to-head meetings when ‘Tubs’ was working with inferior talent. Known in some parts as ‘The Riverboat Gambler,’ Tuberville was a great hire by Texas Tech. He’ll have job security at the West Texas school and won’t have to constantly be paranoid by an administration run by someone (Bobby Lowder) out to get him.
#3: Skip Holtz (South Florida) -- Very unfortunate situation at USF with the way Jim Leavitt went out after building the program up from scratch. But the Bulls had to move on and did so by hiring Holtz, who had built a consistent winner at East Carolina. Obviously, he’s got the last name and solid coaching DNA.
#4: Doc Holliday (Marshall) -- Holliday has been one of the country’s premier recruiters for many years. There might not be a coach in America who has more connections in South Florida, where he’s plucked players from Dade, Broward and Palm Beach Counties up to West Va., North Carolina St. and Florida when he was the recruiting coordinator at those schools. Remember Chuck Amato’s shocking success at N.C. St. at this time a decade ago? Other than Philip Rivers, no one deserves more credit for the Wolfpack’s brief rise up the ACC food chain than Holliday. He left N.C. St. for Florida in 2005 and was an integral part of the Gators’ success under Urban Meyer. Holliday came back to West Va. to work under Bill Stewart the last two seasons before getting his first head-coaching gig at Marshall. Bobby Pruett proved you can win at the school located in Huntington, WV. Pruett, you may recall, produced NFL players like Randy Moss, Eric Kresser, Chad Pennington, Byron Leftwich and Darius Watts. Give Holliday a few years to bring in his players and the Thundering Herd might climb to the top of Conference USA. However, he’ll remain a favorite in Morgantown and when Stewart’s days are done, Marshall could have a hard time keeping Holliday from returning to the Mountaineers.
#5: Charlie Strong (Louisville) -- Other than a forgettable one-game stretch as Florida’s interim head coach after Ron Zook was fired, the only knock critics can possibly have on Strong is his lack of head coaching experience. But when it comes to preparation as an assistant, Strong’s resume has been ready for a major head coaching job for several years. He’s worked under some of the greatest coaches in NCAA history like Steve Spurrier, Lou Holtz and Urban Meyer. He’s worked at programs with rabid fan bases like Notre Dame, South Carolina, Ole Miss and Florida. Strong was defensive coordinator for a pair of national-title teams at UF and has always proven to be an elite recruiter. Bobby Petrino went 41-9 during a glorious four-year tenure before Steve Kragthorpe ran this program into the ground the last three years. Strong is left to pick up the pieces, but it says here that he’ll get the job done.
#6: Joker Phillips (Kentucky) -- The head coach-in-waiting scenario seems to have worked out just right at Kentucky. Phillips becomes the second African-American head coach in SEC history (assuming you don’t count Strong’s one-game stretch at UF) after Sylvester Croom at Mississippi State. He’s served as UK’s recruiting coordinator and offensive coordinator and also played at UK. Like Strong, this is Phillips’ first head-coaching gig, but that’s the only knock any critic could have on him.
#7: Jimbo Fisher (FSU) -- There were certainly chemistry issues galore on the FSU coaching staff the last few years. Part of the staff, including long-timers Chuck Amato and Mickey Andrews, wanted Bobby Bowden to remain in power indefinitely, while others were ready for the legend to step aside. The results, or lack thereof, and then the administration took care of the latter. So now Fisher gets his shot after ho-hum performances as the team’s offensive coordinator since he came to Tallahassee from LSU. He did do an outstanding job with his first recruiting class and I like the hiring of defensive coordinator Mark Stoops. We’ll see how it goes for Fisher, but I certainly have my doubts.
#8: Turner Gill (Kansas) -- Gill nearly landed the Auburn job in 2009 after leading Buffalo to the MAC title. His career record in four seasons with the Bulls was 20-30, but we have to remember that when he took over Buffalo might have bee the nation’s worst program. Obviously, Gill is extremely familiar with the Big 12 after playing at Nebraska and then spending 13 seasons on the Cornhuskers’ coaching staff. He has vowed to recruit, recruit and then recruit some more. Gill inherits a KU program that’s in a lot better shape than when Mark Mangino came to Lawrence from Oklahoma.
#9: Butch Jones (Cincinnati) -- For the second time, Jones is following in Brian Kelly’s footsteps. First, he took over at Central Michigan and to his credit, kept the good times rolling. Granted, he’s had a star QB in Dan LeFevour for all but two of his career games as a head coach, but that tandem produced a stellar 27-13 overall record and a 20-3 mark in MAC play. Also, CMU went into East Lansing and beat Michigan St. last year. Don’t anticipate the Bearcats going unbeaten in the regular season anytime soon, however, especially after losing QB Tony Pike and All-American WR Mardy Gilyard.
#10: Derek Dooley (Tennessee) -- This coaching search turned into a laughable episode, at least for UT’s SEC adversaries. After taking Heisman treatment (getting denied) by a slew of potential candidates, AD Mike Hamilton settled for La. Tech head coach and AD Derek Dooley who, like Holtz, certainly has the DNA to get the job done. But he certainly seemed like a major reach at the time, especially when you think about what a coveted job this is. Nevertheless, I started to come around somewhat on Dooley during his introductory presser. For starters, the Vols have a better coach in Dooley than they had in his predecessor – period! Then again, you can only go up from that chump. But in Dooley you also get quite a bit of Nick Saban, who has enjoyed roaring success in the SEC. And that’s another thing – Dooley is obviously quite familiar with the league, growing up in Vince’s house in Athens and spending a number of years with Saban at LSU. UT also has a class act running the show now, and the program doesn’t need to worry about getting placed on probation, something that seemed a near certainty at this time a year ago. I’m rooting for Dooley to be successful, but UT fans have to be patient. The personnel is just not up to par with the Florida’s, Alabama’s and LSU’s right now.
#11: Lane Kiffin (USC) -- Speaking of Lame Chafin’, the passive-aggressive scoundrel went and did it again – somehow landing yet another high-profile job without accomplishing a thing as a head coach with the Oakland Raiders and the Tennessee Vols. In fact, his most noticeable achievements are the six secondary NCAA violations his staff committed at UT, in addition to the ongoing investigation for sending female students to high school games of UT recruits (a blatant violation of NCAA rules). What made Kiffin’s hire even more stunning is the fact that the NCAA is expected to drop the hammer on the Trojans soon, possibly as early as this week. Therefore, to hire a coach who was on the staff during the Reggie Bush days and one that’s also flirted with NCAA sanctions in the 14 months prior to his hire, is seemingly an act of disrespect to the NCAA. Whatever the case, we will continue to credit Kiffin with one thing and that’s assembling a great staff. Granted, that starts with his father Monte, who is perhaps the best defensive coordinator to ever step on the sidelines of a football field. And, warts and all, recruiting coordinator Ed Orgeron does bring in the blue-chippers. However, let me clearly warn USC fans that the Pete Carroll Era is over and to think that Kiffin’s staff will simply keep the ball rolling is delusional.
**B.E.’s Bonus Nuggets**
--I left new Virginia head coach Mike London out of this discussion simply because I’m not familiar enough with the former Richmond head coach. His tenure at UVA starts by facing his former team, the Spiders. Then the Cavs go out West to face USC. Remember, the Trojans recently beat the Wahoos by a 52-7 count in Charlottesville.
--One of the other big winners in the coaching carousel that we haven’t mentioned yet is Duke. When David Cutcliffe made what I thought was a brilliant decision to turn down Tennessee, the Vols were left stunned. And the Blue Devils were left rejoicing. Cutcliffe has done an outstanding job since taking over in Durham and bettors should continue to look at Duke in big underdog situations on Cut’s watch.
--Hottest Hot Seats for 2010:
1-Rich Rodriguez (Michigan)
2-Dan Hawkins (Colorado)
3-Ron Zook (Illinois)
4-Ralph Friedgen (Maryland)
5-Dennis Erickson (Arizona St.)
--I left Georgia’s Mark Richt and LSU’s Les Miles off of that list but make no mistake, both men had better run a tight ship in 2010. Richt has done an outstanding job at UGA overall, but the program seems to have hit a lull the last two seasons and is still getting beaten like a drum by arch-rival Florida. Perhaps most importantly, Richt was hired by Dooley and AD Damon Evans seems to be itching to bring in his own man. As for The Mad Hatter, well, he showed his lack of coaching acumen in the Tigers’ loss at Ole Miss last year. If Michigan comes calling again, he’ll say ‘yes’ and they won’t lose a wink of sleep about it on the Bayou.
#1: Brian Kelly (Notre Dame) -- The Irish struck out in trying to hire Urban Meyer several years ago, settling instead for Charlie Weis. As we know, that didn’t go so well. This time around, Notre Dame got it right, plucking the hottest coach on the market away from Cincinnati. Eighteen months ago, I wrote that “Tennessee will regret not hiring Brian Kelly instead of Lane Kiffin for decades.” I thoroughly stand by that remark. Kelly has done an outstanding job in prior tenures at Central Michigan and Cincinnati, where he led the Bearcats to an unbeaten regular season in 2009. The only blemish on his resume is so-so recruiting classes the last few years, but now he has a great product in Notre Dame football to sell.
#2: Tommy Tuberville (Texas Tech) -- I’m still floored that Tuberville and former Tennessee head coach Phil Fulmer didn’t generate more interest from other schools in their coaching searches. When the Mike Leach fiasco went down, however, Tuberville was wisely hired by the Red Raiders. The dude just knows how to coach. He won at Ole Miss and won big at Auburn, including a 13-0 record in 2004. Tuberville has beaten Urban Meyer in both head-to-head meetings when ‘Tubs’ was working with inferior talent. Known in some parts as ‘The Riverboat Gambler,’ Tuberville was a great hire by Texas Tech. He’ll have job security at the West Texas school and won’t have to constantly be paranoid by an administration run by someone (Bobby Lowder) out to get him.
#3: Skip Holtz (South Florida) -- Very unfortunate situation at USF with the way Jim Leavitt went out after building the program up from scratch. But the Bulls had to move on and did so by hiring Holtz, who had built a consistent winner at East Carolina. Obviously, he’s got the last name and solid coaching DNA.
#4: Doc Holliday (Marshall) -- Holliday has been one of the country’s premier recruiters for many years. There might not be a coach in America who has more connections in South Florida, where he’s plucked players from Dade, Broward and Palm Beach Counties up to West Va., North Carolina St. and Florida when he was the recruiting coordinator at those schools. Remember Chuck Amato’s shocking success at N.C. St. at this time a decade ago? Other than Philip Rivers, no one deserves more credit for the Wolfpack’s brief rise up the ACC food chain than Holliday. He left N.C. St. for Florida in 2005 and was an integral part of the Gators’ success under Urban Meyer. Holliday came back to West Va. to work under Bill Stewart the last two seasons before getting his first head-coaching gig at Marshall. Bobby Pruett proved you can win at the school located in Huntington, WV. Pruett, you may recall, produced NFL players like Randy Moss, Eric Kresser, Chad Pennington, Byron Leftwich and Darius Watts. Give Holliday a few years to bring in his players and the Thundering Herd might climb to the top of Conference USA. However, he’ll remain a favorite in Morgantown and when Stewart’s days are done, Marshall could have a hard time keeping Holliday from returning to the Mountaineers.
#5: Charlie Strong (Louisville) -- Other than a forgettable one-game stretch as Florida’s interim head coach after Ron Zook was fired, the only knock critics can possibly have on Strong is his lack of head coaching experience. But when it comes to preparation as an assistant, Strong’s resume has been ready for a major head coaching job for several years. He’s worked under some of the greatest coaches in NCAA history like Steve Spurrier, Lou Holtz and Urban Meyer. He’s worked at programs with rabid fan bases like Notre Dame, South Carolina, Ole Miss and Florida. Strong was defensive coordinator for a pair of national-title teams at UF and has always proven to be an elite recruiter. Bobby Petrino went 41-9 during a glorious four-year tenure before Steve Kragthorpe ran this program into the ground the last three years. Strong is left to pick up the pieces, but it says here that he’ll get the job done.
#6: Joker Phillips (Kentucky) -- The head coach-in-waiting scenario seems to have worked out just right at Kentucky. Phillips becomes the second African-American head coach in SEC history (assuming you don’t count Strong’s one-game stretch at UF) after Sylvester Croom at Mississippi State. He’s served as UK’s recruiting coordinator and offensive coordinator and also played at UK. Like Strong, this is Phillips’ first head-coaching gig, but that’s the only knock any critic could have on him.
#7: Jimbo Fisher (FSU) -- There were certainly chemistry issues galore on the FSU coaching staff the last few years. Part of the staff, including long-timers Chuck Amato and Mickey Andrews, wanted Bobby Bowden to remain in power indefinitely, while others were ready for the legend to step aside. The results, or lack thereof, and then the administration took care of the latter. So now Fisher gets his shot after ho-hum performances as the team’s offensive coordinator since he came to Tallahassee from LSU. He did do an outstanding job with his first recruiting class and I like the hiring of defensive coordinator Mark Stoops. We’ll see how it goes for Fisher, but I certainly have my doubts.
#8: Turner Gill (Kansas) -- Gill nearly landed the Auburn job in 2009 after leading Buffalo to the MAC title. His career record in four seasons with the Bulls was 20-30, but we have to remember that when he took over Buffalo might have bee the nation’s worst program. Obviously, Gill is extremely familiar with the Big 12 after playing at Nebraska and then spending 13 seasons on the Cornhuskers’ coaching staff. He has vowed to recruit, recruit and then recruit some more. Gill inherits a KU program that’s in a lot better shape than when Mark Mangino came to Lawrence from Oklahoma.
#9: Butch Jones (Cincinnati) -- For the second time, Jones is following in Brian Kelly’s footsteps. First, he took over at Central Michigan and to his credit, kept the good times rolling. Granted, he’s had a star QB in Dan LeFevour for all but two of his career games as a head coach, but that tandem produced a stellar 27-13 overall record and a 20-3 mark in MAC play. Also, CMU went into East Lansing and beat Michigan St. last year. Don’t anticipate the Bearcats going unbeaten in the regular season anytime soon, however, especially after losing QB Tony Pike and All-American WR Mardy Gilyard.
#10: Derek Dooley (Tennessee) -- This coaching search turned into a laughable episode, at least for UT’s SEC adversaries. After taking Heisman treatment (getting denied) by a slew of potential candidates, AD Mike Hamilton settled for La. Tech head coach and AD Derek Dooley who, like Holtz, certainly has the DNA to get the job done. But he certainly seemed like a major reach at the time, especially when you think about what a coveted job this is. Nevertheless, I started to come around somewhat on Dooley during his introductory presser. For starters, the Vols have a better coach in Dooley than they had in his predecessor – period! Then again, you can only go up from that chump. But in Dooley you also get quite a bit of Nick Saban, who has enjoyed roaring success in the SEC. And that’s another thing – Dooley is obviously quite familiar with the league, growing up in Vince’s house in Athens and spending a number of years with Saban at LSU. UT also has a class act running the show now, and the program doesn’t need to worry about getting placed on probation, something that seemed a near certainty at this time a year ago. I’m rooting for Dooley to be successful, but UT fans have to be patient. The personnel is just not up to par with the Florida’s, Alabama’s and LSU’s right now.
#11: Lane Kiffin (USC) -- Speaking of Lame Chafin’, the passive-aggressive scoundrel went and did it again – somehow landing yet another high-profile job without accomplishing a thing as a head coach with the Oakland Raiders and the Tennessee Vols. In fact, his most noticeable achievements are the six secondary NCAA violations his staff committed at UT, in addition to the ongoing investigation for sending female students to high school games of UT recruits (a blatant violation of NCAA rules). What made Kiffin’s hire even more stunning is the fact that the NCAA is expected to drop the hammer on the Trojans soon, possibly as early as this week. Therefore, to hire a coach who was on the staff during the Reggie Bush days and one that’s also flirted with NCAA sanctions in the 14 months prior to his hire, is seemingly an act of disrespect to the NCAA. Whatever the case, we will continue to credit Kiffin with one thing and that’s assembling a great staff. Granted, that starts with his father Monte, who is perhaps the best defensive coordinator to ever step on the sidelines of a football field. And, warts and all, recruiting coordinator Ed Orgeron does bring in the blue-chippers. However, let me clearly warn USC fans that the Pete Carroll Era is over and to think that Kiffin’s staff will simply keep the ball rolling is delusional.
**B.E.’s Bonus Nuggets**
--I left new Virginia head coach Mike London out of this discussion simply because I’m not familiar enough with the former Richmond head coach. His tenure at UVA starts by facing his former team, the Spiders. Then the Cavs go out West to face USC. Remember, the Trojans recently beat the Wahoos by a 52-7 count in Charlottesville.
--One of the other big winners in the coaching carousel that we haven’t mentioned yet is Duke. When David Cutcliffe made what I thought was a brilliant decision to turn down Tennessee, the Vols were left stunned. And the Blue Devils were left rejoicing. Cutcliffe has done an outstanding job since taking over in Durham and bettors should continue to look at Duke in big underdog situations on Cut’s watch.
--Hottest Hot Seats for 2010:
1-Rich Rodriguez (Michigan)
2-Dan Hawkins (Colorado)
3-Ron Zook (Illinois)
4-Ralph Friedgen (Maryland)
5-Dennis Erickson (Arizona St.)
--I left Georgia’s Mark Richt and LSU’s Les Miles off of that list but make no mistake, both men had better run a tight ship in 2010. Richt has done an outstanding job at UGA overall, but the program seems to have hit a lull the last two seasons and is still getting beaten like a drum by arch-rival Florida. Perhaps most importantly, Richt was hired by Dooley and AD Damon Evans seems to be itching to bring in his own man. As for The Mad Hatter, well, he showed his lack of coaching acumen in the Tigers’ loss at Ole Miss last year. If Michigan comes calling again, he’ll say ‘yes’ and they won’t lose a wink of sleep about it on the Bayou.
Comment