Fantasy Question!

[Dat Boi E]

Santonio Holmes @ Philly with a hurt knee or Jonathan Stewart @ Minny?

[longnex]

I say Holmes unless you are playing me then I say Stewart.

[Dat Boi E]

I say Holmes unless you are playing me then I say Stewart.

thnx, that's what i was think'n 2!

[wayne1218]

I'm starting both but i would take Stewart over Holmes!

[Dat Boi E]

I'm starting both but i would take Stewart over Holmes!

thnx, Wayne!

[wayne1218]

I think Stewart is a Stud and this years AP. Holmes has been up and down so far and nursing an injury!

[Dat Boi E]

I think Stewart is a Stud and this years AP. Holmes has been up and down so far and nursing an injury!

10-4!

[Tornado3311]

Sorry wayne but NO WAY you start stewart at Minny. If you see this E I would go with Santonio cause Minny's run defense is stifling especially at home

[wayne1218]

Sorry wayne but NO WAY you start stewart at Minny. If you see this E I would go with Santonio cause Minny's run defense is stifling especially at home

I know all about Minny's run defense and i have both players on my fantasy team. We differ on our opinions i guess.

[wayne1218]

I don't know how your league is scored but i know in mine, Holmes had 3.45 points and Stewart had 14.00 points. Not so crazy after all tornado!

[Tornado3311]

14 points??????????????????????????

Please get me in the league that you get 14 points for:
7 att 15 yds TD.

In a standard league (ppr) Holmes had 3 for 32 = 6.2 and Stewart got 7.5

[longnex]

I don't know how your league is scored but i know in mine, Holmes had 3.45 points and Stewart had 14.00 points. Not so crazy after all tornado!

Most leagues dont give credit for return yards like your does. Most leagues Stewart would have 7 points. Either way Stewart had more points.

[wayne1218]

14 points??????????????????????????

Please get me in the league that you get 14 points for:
7 att 15 yds TD.

In a standard league (ppr) Holmes had 3 for 32 = 6.2 and Stewart got 7.5

You get return yards in our league's.

Either way, it doesn't matter. If you eliminate return yards in our league, Stewart still had 7.5 points to Holmes 3.45. Neither is great but one still double's the other.

[wayne1218]

14 points??????????????????????????

Please get me in the league that you get 14 points for:
7 att 15 yds TD.

In a standard league (ppr) Holmes had 3 for 32 = 6.2 and Stewart got 7.5

ppr are about as dumb as ppc with RB's. Yardage and TD's ... along with turnovers.

[wayne1218]

Most leagues dont give credit for return yards like your does. Most leagues Stewart would have 7 points. Either way Stewart had more points.

I know, but most league's are not 16-20 teams. That is why those were added in a few years ago. People needed guys and having return yards count helped a little.