Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Amputee runner wins right to try for Olympic spot

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Amputee runner wins right to try for Olympic spot

    LAUSANNE, Switzerland (AP) -- Double-amputee sprinter Oscar Pistorius won his appeal Friday and can compete for a place in the Beijing Olympics.

    The Court of Arbitration for Sport ruled that the 21-year-old South African is eligible to race against able-bodied athletes, overturning a ban imposed by the International Association of Athletics Federations.

    CAS said the unanimous ruling goes into effect immediately.

    Pistorius still must reach a qualifying time to run in the individual 400 meters at the Aug. 8-24 Beijing Games. However, he can be picked for the South African relay squad without qualifying.

    Pistorius appealed to CAS, world sport's highest tribunal, to overturn a Jan. 14 ruling by the IAAF that banned him from competing. The IAAF said his carbon fiber blades give him a mechanical advantage.

    A two-day hearing was held before a panel of three arbitrators at CAS headquarters last month.

    Pistorius holds the 400-meter Paralympic world record of 46.56 seconds, but that time is outside the Olympic qualifying standard of 45.55. His training has been disrupted by the appeal process.

    Even if Pistorius fails to get the qualifying time, South African selectors could add the University of Pretoria student to the Olympic 1,600-meter relay squad.

    Pistorius would not require a qualifying time and could be taken to Beijing as an alternate. Six runners can be picked for the relay squad. Pistorius also expects to compete in Beijing at the Sept. 6-17 Paralympic Games.

    The verdict also clears Pistorius to dedicate himself to competing at the 2012 London Olympics.

    The IAAF based its January decision on studies by German professor Gert-Peter Brueggemann, who said the J-shaped "Cheetah" blades were energy efficient.

    Pistorius' lawyers countered with independent tests conducted by a team led by MIT professor Hugh M. Herr that claimed to show he doesn't gain any advantage over able-bodied runners.

    CAS said the IAAF failed to prove that Pistorius' running blades give him an advantage.

    "The panel was not persuaded that there was sufficient evidence of any metabolic advantage in favor of a double-amputee using the Cheetah Flex-Foot," CAS said. "Furthermore, the CAS panel has considered that the IAAF did not prove that the biomechanical effects of using this particular prosthetic device gives Oscar Pistorius an advantage over other athletes not using the device."

    Pistorius was born without fibulas -- the long, thin outer bone between the knee and ankle -- and was 11 months old when his legs were amputated below the knee.

  • #2
    Has anyone seen this guy run? He's amazing!

    Comment


    • #3
      Frank - I have seen him. The concern was that the flex gear might enable him to have an advantage- so this is good news. Certainly enables the company to advertise him.
      Since he is only just over the mark for qualifying- that alone should get him in as he practices, however, it would be a nice PR source for the South Africans to have him on the team- I imagine.
      "The range of what we think and do is limited by what we fail to notice.

      Comment


      • #4
        More power to this guy for his acheivements but if he put super springs on those things and High Jumped a world record what would you think???

        Its a cool story though.
        NBA is a joke

        Comment


        • #5
          i hope he wins GOLD
          MLB 2012***100-98 +$215 OR +2.15 UNITS
          HUGE PLAYS 2-1

          NFL 2011-2012** 6-10
          0-0TOP PLAYS

          NCAA FBL 2011-2012**** 26-23

          4-1 TOP PLAYS


          GOY 33-12 ALL SPORTS

          AS of 6/3/12

          Comment


          • #6
            It's a great story, but he doesn't belong in the Olympics. The coil of the springs give him a distinct advantage (IMO). Plus he doesn't have to worry about lower leg problems (achilles, calve, shin splints, foot problems)...I commend him for his strength to continue his dream...but that's what the paraolympics are for....Plus he states he will run in them also, he should have to choose one or the other...

            Comment


            • #7
              go for it, thats how i look at it
              Questions, comments, complaints:
              [email protected]

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by JMR58
                It's a great story, but he doesn't belong in the Olympics. The coil of the springs give him a distinct advantage (IMO). Plus he doesn't have to worry about lower leg problems (achilles, calve, shin splints, foot problems)...I commend him for his strength to continue his dream...but that's what the paraolympics are for....Plus he states he will run in them also, he should have to choose one or the other...

                I HAVE TO DISAGREE.JUST BECAUSE YOU HAVE A MEDICAL PROBLEM THAT SHOULD NOT MATTER IN LIFE.HE HAD A DREAM TO BE IN THE OLYMPICS LET HIM DO IT.JUST BECAUSE OF A MEDICAL CONDITION YOU SHOULD BE ABLE TO ACHIEVE EVERYTHING YOU WANTED IN LIFE
                MLB 2012***100-98 +$215 OR +2.15 UNITS
                HUGE PLAYS 2-1

                NFL 2011-2012** 6-10
                0-0TOP PLAYS

                NCAA FBL 2011-2012**** 26-23

                4-1 TOP PLAYS


                GOY 33-12 ALL SPORTS

                AS of 6/3/12

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by tech fan
                  I HAVE TO DISAGREE.JUST BECAUSE YOU HAVE A MEDICAL PROBLEM THAT SHOULD NOT MATTER IN LIFE.HE HAD A DREAM TO BE IN THE OLYMPICS LET HIM DO IT.JUST BECAUSE OF A MEDICAL CONDITION YOU SHOULD BE ABLE TO ACHIEVE EVERYTHING YOU WANTED IN LIFE
                  So why not let him ride a Harley too?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by griswold
                    So why not let him ride a Harley too?

                    i just think that you should not tell someone No for something they work so hard for when its not thier own problem.If he could pass a driving test on a HARLEY then why not
                    MLB 2012***100-98 +$215 OR +2.15 UNITS
                    HUGE PLAYS 2-1

                    NFL 2011-2012** 6-10
                    0-0TOP PLAYS

                    NCAA FBL 2011-2012**** 26-23

                    4-1 TOP PLAYS


                    GOY 33-12 ALL SPORTS

                    AS of 6/3/12

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      It's fine for right now because he's not really fast enough to even threaten for a medal, but what happens when the technology improves and he just keeps getting faster? There's no way they would ever consider allowing wheelchair competitors to participate in the Olympic Marathon because the best in the world are 30 minutes faster than any able-bodied runner in the world, but this guy gets to compete because of one study by a professor at MIT who just happens to be a double amputee himself. I would be really surprised if this isn't overturned before 2012.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by ctt8410
                        It's fine for right now because he's not really fast enough to even threaten for a medal, but what happens when the technology improves and he just keeps getting faster? There's no way they would ever consider allowing wheelchair competitors to participate in the Olympic Marathon because the best in the world are 30 minutes faster than any able-bodied runner in the world, but this guy gets to compete because of one study by a professor at MIT who just happens to be a double amputee himself. I would be really surprised if this isn't overturned before 2012.

                        this is my opinion on this subject.If a guy in a wheelchair enters a marathon he is not using his legs he is using his arms and that would be an unfair advantage.This guy lost his legs but still had a dream to be in the olympics.This guy was a great track and field star before he lost his legs.So what would you do if you were him.Put yourself in his shoes"no pun intended" would you just give up or would it drive you to do something no one has ever done.The thing i like about him was when the ruling came down he said ,"THIS IS THE BEST DAY OF MY LIFE" AND THE THING THAT GOT MY ATTENTION BY SAYING THIS IS A GREAT DAY FOR EVERYONE THAT IS HANDICAPPED .LET THE GUY RUN HE WONT WIN A MEDAL HIS GOLD MEDAL IS JUST MAKING THE OLYMPICS AND BEING THERE AND WALKING DURING THE OPENING CEROMONIES
                        MLB 2012***100-98 +$215 OR +2.15 UNITS
                        HUGE PLAYS 2-1

                        NFL 2011-2012** 6-10
                        0-0TOP PLAYS

                        NCAA FBL 2011-2012**** 26-23

                        4-1 TOP PLAYS


                        GOY 33-12 ALL SPORTS

                        AS of 6/3/12

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          This Guy Is More Qualified Than The Jamacian Bobsled Team And That Ski Jumper Think His Name Was Eddie The Eagle Edwards Not Sure That Guy Was An Embarasementhe Was There Just To Get His Name Out Not For The Good And Helping Other People That Have A Condition And Show Them Never Give Up
                          MLB 2012***100-98 +$215 OR +2.15 UNITS
                          HUGE PLAYS 2-1

                          NFL 2011-2012** 6-10
                          0-0TOP PLAYS

                          NCAA FBL 2011-2012**** 26-23

                          4-1 TOP PLAYS


                          GOY 33-12 ALL SPORTS

                          AS of 6/3/12

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Read the article in Runners World, April 2008 issue (page 28), extensive studies have proved that there's less energy loss, superior energy return, equal speed less energy, less vertical motion, and less fatigue...overall the prosthetics legs give Pistorius an advantage over able bodied runners, thus he should be banned.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by JMR58
                              It's a great story, but he doesn't belong in the Olympics. The coil of the springs give him a distinct advantage (IMO). Plus he doesn't have to worry about lower leg problems (achilles, calve, shin splints, foot problems)...I commend him for his strength to continue his dream...but that's what the paraolympics are for....Plus he states he will run in them also, he should have to choose one or the other...
                              He doesn't have to worry about leg problems.......

                              I'm sure all disabled people and amputees are relieved that they don't have to "worry" about their particular "problems".

                              Amazing.

                              Steven Hawking doesn't have to "worry" about straining any muscles, Stevie Wonder doesn't have to "worry" about witnessing a horrible tragedy, and Helen Keller didn't have to "worry" about hearing nasty gossip about her.

                              While I agree that it is probably unfair to the other able-bodied contestants, I must take exception to this statement.
                              You can't always get what you want, but if you try some time, you might find, you get what you need.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X