Vince Young

[TwoTonTony]

he certainly is improving for a rookie and lets not forget...he is a rookie and on a crap team......Look back at all the qb's who started their rookie years and had success....not many....

I am not ready to crown him an all-pro, but he desreves some credit for sure and looks promising

[Tinman1960]

was that the biggest choke in NFL history? 21 with 9 mins left?

PEACE

I THINK THERE WERE SOME WORST BUT THAT ONE IS CLOSE I REMEMBER A MONDAYNIGHT GAME AROUND 12 TO 14 YEARS AGO I REMEMBER PHILLY WAS PLAYING IT I HAD PHILLY AND THERE WAS LIKE 6 MINUTES TO GO PHILLY WAS I THINK -4 OR -5 I SHUT THE TV OFF WOKE UP INTHE MORNING AND SAW IN THE PAPER WHERETHEY WON AND EVEN COVERED THE SPREAD I PRETTY SURE THEY WERE DOWN BY 14 WITH 6 MINUTES TO GO

[Tinman1960]

he certainly is improving for a rookie and lets not forget...he is a rookie and on a crap team......Look back at all the qb's who started their rookie years and had success....not many....

I am not ready to crown him an all-pro, but he desreves some credit for sure and looks promising

THAT GUY NEEDS TO TAKE CHARGE ON THE FIELD HE DOSE NOT SAY 2 WORDS TO ANYONE LOOK AT YOUNG TODAY HE WAS YELLING ALL OVER THE PLACE AND HE HAS LESS GAMES UNDER HIS BELT THAN MANNING I THINK THE GIANTS MADE A BAD TRADE TO GET HIM

[kbsooner21]

You're joking, right? Heinous crime? Everyone was saying the same things about Vick, when he first started, that you are saying in this thread.

Let's temper the enthusiasm until this guy has more than 1 good quarter as a pro.

1 good quarter??? I believe he has led his team to wins in 4 out of the last 5 games

[TwoTonTony]

THAT GUY NEEDS TO TAKE CHARGE ON THE FIELD HE DOSE NOT SAY 2 WORDS TO ANYONE LOOK AT YOUNG TODAY HE WAS YELLING ALL OVER THE PLACE AND HE HAS LESS GAMES UNDER HIS BELT THAN MANNING I THINK THE GIANTS MADE A BAD TRADE TO GET HIM

it is very hard to speculate what make a qb successful....is it yelling??? some guys do....others do not......Qb's mature at different rates.....Am i ready to give up on Eli??? pretty close, but not entirely since we have no choice in the matter.....

It is a unique position and some do not find any success until their 30's (gannon and plunkett) whereas some find early success only to find it fleeting.....

[rented mule]

1 good quarter??? I believe he has led his team to wins in 4 out of the last 5 games

KB....with all due respect, his stats have been borderline terrible in each game he's played, win or lose. They have won 4 of 6 and clearly he did a nice job today, although I would fault the Giants' 2nd half game plan as much as i'd give Vince Young credit.

In each of two of those wins, the Titans had a defensive and special teams TD, so i'm really not sure how much Young can be credited with "leading" them to those wins.

Again, it's way too early to say how he will end up, but to say he's the future of the league is a little bit over enthusiastic in my opinion.

[griffey_mojo]

1 good quarter??? I believe he has led his team to wins in 4 out of the last 5 games

He led them to those wins? IMO his numbers don't show that and I must add....I didn't watch ANY of the TEN games.

Week 6 W 25-22 @ 4-7 WAS
13-25 for 161 1TD 0 INT

Week 7 BYE

Week 8 W 28-22 vs 3-8 HOU
7-15 for 87 1 TD 0 INT

Week 9 L 37-7 @ 6-5 JAC
16-36 for 163 1 TD 3 INT

Week 10 L 27-26 vs 9-2 BAL
13-25 for 211 0 TD 1 INT

Week 11 W 31-13 @ 5-5 PHI
8-22 for 101 1 TD 0 INT

Week 12 W 24-21 vs 6-5 NYG
24-35 for 249 2 TD 0 INT

His QB numbers I find Very subpar.

[uconnplayer]

yea PIMP i agree man, Young is legit. Its good to see another rookie qb that handles his own

[Tinman1960]

it is very hard to speculate what make a qb successful....is it yelling??? some guys do....others do not......Qb's mature at different rates.....Am i ready to give up on Eli??? pretty close, but not entirely since we have no choice in the matter.....

It is a unique position and some do not find any success until their 30's (gannon and plunkett) whereas some find early success only to find it fleeting.....

YOU KNOW TONY I THOUGHT THAT KID WAS GOING TO BE REAL GOOD SOME EVEN SAID HE WAS BETTER IN NCAAF THAN HIS BROTHER I NEVER SAW IT BUT. WE JUST HAVE TO WAIT AND SEE IF HE CAN TURN IT AROUND

[Tinman1960]

yea PIMP i agree man, Young is legit. Its good to see another rookie qb that handles his own

I THINK ROMO IS GOING TO BETTER THAN MANNING JMO

[kbsooner21]

He led them to those wins? IMO his numbers don't show that and I must add....I didn't watch ANY of the TEN games.

Week 6 W 25-22 @ 4-7 WAS
13-25 for 161 1TD 0 INT

Week 7 BYE

Week 8 W 28-22 vs 3-8 HOU
7-15 for 87 1 TD 0 INT

Week 9 L 37-7 @ 6-5 JAC
16-36 for 163 1 TD 3 INT

Week 10 L 27-26 vs 9-2 BAL
13-25 for 211 0 TD 1 INT

Week 11 W 31-13 @ 5-5 PHI
8-22 for 101 1 TD 0 INT

Week 12 W 24-21 vs 6-5 NYG
24-35 for 249 2 TD 0 INT

His QB numbers I find Very subpar.

Did someone else play quarterback?? He might not have put up hall of fame numbers in the games, but quarterbacks lead teams to wins and losses. For a rookie on as shitty as a team as the Titans are, I consider those last 4 out of 6 wins more important than any other stat you throw out there.

[TMAC951]

My fantasy team thanks mr. Young for his beautiful day he had today!

[griffey_mojo]

Did someone else play quarterback?? He might not have put up hall of fame numbers in the games, but quarterbacks lead teams to wins and losses. For a rookie on as shitty as a team as the Titans are, I consider those last 4 out of 6 wins more important than any other stat you throw out there.

It would appear to me that anytime he's matched up against a "good" team that they lose. TEN beat PHI and NYG when they both are on a downward spiral. And those two teams are 500.

[kbsooner21]

It would appear to me that anytime he's matched up against a "good" team that they lose. TEN beat PHI and NYG when they both are on a downward spiral. And those two teams are 500.

I bet you thought the NYG were in a downward spiral when they were up 21-0 to start the 4th quarter huh

[frankb03]

I THINK ROMO IS GOING TO BETTER THAN MANNING JMO

Hmmmmmmm

I wonder why you think that?

Romo has been impressive but let's not forget he's faced some shitty teams with shitty defenses. Washington, Arizona, Indy and TB are not going to scare many offensive coordinators. They beat Carolina in the 4th qtr due to turnovers.