Rank the NFL Qb's

[MRhotPICKS]

All this talking about Michael Vick being rather poor and what not has got me wondering who you have ranked in your top 10 quarterbacks in the NFL as of right now...

1. Tom Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Donovan McNabb
4. Carson Palmer
5. Brett Favre(yeah I know his team sucks but ill take him any day)
6. Matt Hasselback

This is where it gets hard because not everyone has had a stellar year... but this is how I see it...
7. Jake Delhomme
8. Daunte Culpepper
9. Eli Manning ( might be much better in a few years.. just not that big a fan of him right now)
10. Brad Johnson( keeps his team in every game and avoids the stupid costly mistakes)
10. Drew Brees (has been very consistant even with team that has been poor over the past few years in New Orleans)

On the outside looking in - Byron Leftwich and Ben Roethlisburger (they do not get to throw enough to be considered top 10 material)

Just my thoughts... any other insights?

[JBC13]

daunte culpepper shouldnt be anywhere near the top 10

[MRhotPICKS]

I do not know if his troubles this year are his fault or the offensive line's fault or just bad preparation for games and opposing defenses... but he is one of the top 10 in the league...

[longnex]

This is my list based on this year only.

1. P Manning
2. Palmer
3. McNabb
4. Hasselback
5. Pennington
6 Carr (sounds stupid but he has the best QB rating of any QB)
7. Grossman
8. E Manning
9. Leftwich
10. Favre

[JBC13]

I do not know if his troubles this year are his fault or the offensive line's fault or just bad preparation for games and opposing defenses... but he is one of the top 10 in the league...

he has time to throw the ball....he holds on to it way to long.....he doesnt know how to read a defense and he is playing scared....he cant just throw the ball up to randy moss anymore....there is no way he is a top ten qb right now....maybe a coulpe years ago.

[tkim11]

I agree. Who is Randy with Culpepper? Who is Culpepper without Randy? They should unite them...OMG if phins had Randy...

Put TO with any QB = DOMINATION with AGGREVATION

[seaofred]

1-peyton manning
2-tom brady
3-carson palmer
4-donovan mcnabb
5-matt hasselbeck
6trent green-ony throws for 4,000 yds a season
7brett favre
8-drew brees
9-steve mcnair-tough as nails
10-jake delhomme

[BettorsChat]

Tom Brady
Peyton Manning
Carson Palmer
Brett Favre

Agree on the above

As for Favre if you put him on a good team they would be even better. He plays on a shitty team with little to no help around him. That franchise is going to have too rebuild.

[MRhotPICKS]

This is my list based on this year only.

1. P Manning
2. Palmer
3. McNabb
4. Hasselback
5. Pennington
6 Carr (sounds stupid but he has the best QB rating of any QB)
7. Grossman
8. E Manning
9. Leftwich
10. Favre

How can you not have Tom Brady in there... the guy just Wins, Wins, Wins... I understand I did say this year, and Chad Carr and Grossman have had stellar seasons so far, but there is no way it continues... I just do not see it happening... maybe I am wrong and would have rather had David Carr instead of Culpepper in Miami... who knows

[10DimeBry]

based on this year only:

1. D.McNabb
2. C. palmer
3. T. Brady
4. M. Hasselback
5. D. Brees
6. B. Johnson
7. R. Grossman
8. P. Manning
9. J. Delhomme
10.B. Farve

[longnex]

How can you not have Tom Brady in there... the guy just Wins, Wins, Wins... I understand I did say this year, and Chad Carr and Grossman have had stellar seasons so far, but there is no way it continues... I just do not see it happening... maybe I am wrong and would have rather had David Carr instead of Culpepper in Miami... who knows

I was basing my picks on this year only. The first 3 games. I wasnt speculating on how they are going to do. I based it on what they did already.

[kbsooner21]

based on this year only:

1. D.McNabb
2. C. palmer
3. T. Brady
4. M. Hasselback
5. D. Brees
6. B. Johnson
7. R. Grossman
8. P. Manning
9. J. Delhomme
10.B. Farve

based on this year only??? and you have manning down at 8?? put down the hippie lettuce bro

[JBC13]

based on this year only:

1. D.McNabb
2. C. palmer
3. T. Brady
4. M. Hasselback
5. D. Brees
6. B. Johnson
7. R. Grossman
8. P. Manning
9. J. Delhomme
10.B. Farve

tom brady cant be 3rd you homer....broncos tore his ass up

[kbsooner21]

1. Peyton Manning
2. Carson Palmer
3. Donovan McNabb
4. Drew Brees
5. Tom Brady
6. Rex Grossman
7. Brad Johnson
8. Chad Pennington
9. Brett Favre
10. Matt Hasselback

[longnex]

Tom Brady this year has a 78.5 QB rating. He has 4 TDs and 2 Int. He also fumbled 3 times. How can he even be in the top 10 this year?