Manning vs Palmer

[TheRook]

If you had to have one quarterback on your team based on these two...who would they be?

Peyton Manning

Carson Palmer

[RJeremy]

Peyton Manning BY FAR!!!!!!!!!!!!


He's a genious mastermind!

[10DimeBry]

i wanted to vote for horton but i settled for palmer.

[10DimeBry]

also please look at our MVP poll manning finished tied for 4th. The proof is right there rook go look for yourself. I'd bump it but its locked

[TheRook]

also please look at our MVP poll manning finished tied for 4th. The proof is right there rook go look for yourself. I'd bump it but its locked

Which has what to do with this poll again?

Oh that's right...nothing.

[10DimeBry]

ok fine but your getting away from my inital point. that is 2nd place in MVP voting shouldnt have gone to manning

[RJeremy]

Looks like Bry is the only one that voted for Palmer

[kbsooner21]

Is this really even a question???

[jcindaville]

Tommy Maddux hands down

[TheRook]

Is this really even a question???

Obviously it is buddy...since our resident Manning hater would rather have Palmer then Manning....so I wanted to see if he was alone in that...