Which QB would you want starting for your team?

[jcindaville]

Rodgers
Brees
Brady
Big Ben

[kbsooner21]

TEBOW
Fitzpatick
Brees
Brady
Big Ben

Just cause he ousted you out of the playoffs doesn't mean he's a great QB!

[diesel]

(1) Rodgers

(2) Brees

(3) Brady

(4) Eli Manning

(5) Peyton Manning

(6) Big Ben

Who would everyone else round out the top 10 with?

[Letswinalot]

(1) Rodgers

(2) Brees

(3) Brady

(4) Eli Manning

(5) Peyton Manning

(6) Big Ben

Who would everyone else round out the top 10 with?

Cam, Rivers, Dalton, Schaub(if his ass would ever stay healthy)

[wayne1218]

Cam, Rivers, Dalton, Schaub(if his ass would ever stay healthy)

Stafford HAS TO be in there after the season he had. His stats were better than Eli during the reg season. Hell, they were better than all but about 2 or 3 QB's. I would also put Ryan and Romo in there too. Dalton and Schaub would not be top 10 for me. Cam maybe, but probably not just yet.

[jcindaville]

Just cause he ousted you out of the playoffs doesn't mean he's a great QB!

Lmao

[Big Country 5]

Brees,by alot
Rodgers
Brady
Rapelisberger
Stafford and Cam in a tie.

[Letswinalot]

Stafford HAS TO be in there after the season he had. His stats were better than Eli during the reg season. Hell, they were better than all but about 2 or 3 QB's. I would also put Ryan and Romo in there too. Dalton and Schaub would not be top 10 for me. Cam maybe, but probably not just yet.

Yea I forgot Stafford. He would be in mine over Schuab. Dalton/Cam are just so young that they are intriguing to me. Id take them in the top 10.

[Ldawg]

yea i forgot stafford. He would be in mine over schuab. Dalton/cam are just so young that they are intriguing to me. Id take them in the 6 .

dude ....

[tech fan]

I would go with

Rodgers by a whole lot
Brees
Peyton Manning
Brady
Michael Vick


I know some might be surprised by Vick but if he is on there is no defense that could stop him.

[10DimeBry]

#1 Brees
#2 Rodgers
#3 Peyton Manning
#4 Eli Manning
#5 Brady

#3 must be an error. will blame it on the rum.

[poskid]

Based on both level of play AND the number of years that you are likely to get them at a high level.

1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Eli Manning
3. Drew Brees
4. Ben Rothlisberger
5. Matt Stafford
6. Tom Brady
7. Philip Rivers
8. Cam Newton
9. Tony Romo
10. Alex Smith