Great Quarterbacks That Never Won a SuperBowl

[BettorsChat]

10. John Hadl
9. Jim Everett
8. Ken Anderson
7. Dave Krieg
6. Boomer Esiason
5. Dan Fouts
4. Fran Tarkenton
3. Jim Kelly
2. Dan Marino
1. Warren Moon

The Top Ten NFL Quarterbacks That Never Won a Superbowl

3) Jake Delhomme

Top five greatest quarterbacks to never win a Super Bowl - NFL - Yahoo! Sports

[BettorsChat]

What everyone agrees with this list?

[wayne1218]

I would put Jim Kelly at #1, Marino #2

The rest, i'm not sure about. Krieg wouldn't crack my top 30, and i'm not sure if Jim Everett would either. The others, i could see.

Didn't read the article. That's just my take on those guys.

[BettorsChat]

Jim Kelly was the biggest choke artist of all time.

Mario never got the win, because they never had a RB worth a shit.

[wayne1218]

Jim Kelly was the biggest choke artist of all time.

Mario never got the win, because they never had a RB worth a shit.

Marino was a bigger choker .... but i already debated him here before. Just look at his postseason record. Kelly may not have won but getting to 4 straight is something Marino never had a look at ... cuz he choked games away before ever getting that far!

[BettorsChat]

Marino was a bigger choker .... but i already debated him here before. Just look at his postseason record. Kelly may not have won but getting to 4 straight is something Marino never had a look at ... cuz he choked games away before ever getting that far!

I never liked Jim Kelly! 4 SB's in a row and 4 L's he'll never live that one down.

I was glad that Elway finally got a SB victory.

Dan Fouts, Fran Tarkenton and Moon are 3 that should have won a SB.

[wayne1218]

That doesn't make sense. You fault the guy who got his team to 4 super bowls and lost but you don't fault the guy who could never get to more than 1?

[flarendep1]

For the most part, I agree with Wayne's take and I would bump up Ken Anderson a little.

[jcindaville]

Dan Fouts wasn't that good, Warren Moon either.

Kelly was good, couldn't finish but was damn good.

[BettorsChat]

That doesn't make sense. You fault the guy who got his team to 4 super bowls and lost but you don't fault the guy who could never get to more than 1?

It wasn't just Jim Kelly that got them to a SB. It takes a team to get there.

[BettorsChat]

Dan Fouts wasn't that good, Warren Moon either.

Kelly was good, couldn't finish but was damn good.

I disagree

I don't think Kelly was a better QB than Fouts or Moon.

Fouts, Dan 15 Years 1973 - 1987 TD: 254 Int: 242 Yds: 43,040 Rate: 80.2
1993



Moon, Warren 17 Years 1984 - 2000 TD: 291 Int: 233 Yds: 49,325 Rate: 80.9


Jim Kelley
TOTAL 160 4,779 2,874 60.1 29.9 35,467 7.4 221.7 237 5.0 175 3.7 84 235 48 323 2,427 84.4

Dan Marino
TOTAL 4,967 8,358 59.4 61,361 7.3 420 252 270 1,930 86.4 301 87

Fran Tarkenton

Career 246 239 675 3674 32 52 5.4 14.9 2.7 3662 32 84
13 yrs MIN 177 170 464 2548 22 52 5.

Fran Tarkenton NFL & AFL Football Statistics - Pro-Football-Reference.com

[BettorsChat]

That doesn't make sense. You fault the guy who got his team to 4 super bowls and lost but you don't fault the guy who could never get to more than 1?

Who said I didn't fault them?

Again it takes a team to get too the SB & Win

[wayne1218]

No shit it takes a team. A qb can also carry a team on any given year with limited talent around him

I could care less about numbers. I watched these guys play and I would take kelly

[kbsooner21]

Kelly was great. Running that no huddle with precision. Should have won the first one they were in. Piece of shit Norwood

[slappy's son]

I would take Jim Kelly & Dan Fouts as my top 2, Marino 3rd. The reason Jim Kelly's Buff Bills never won a SB is because the defense gave up 40-50 pts, and Choke-wood misses a chip shot to win!! Getting to 4 Super Bowls in a row may NEVER be matched again! THAT is actually tougher than getting to 1-2 over the course of a career and winning both of them. The SB is only "1" game, and anything can happen, and the best team doesn't always win. And YES, although it takes a whole team to get there, MANY times it's the QB that wins the game and gets them moving to the next round! I would wager my entire 401K that "4" SB's in a row, win or lose, will NEVER be matched again, EVER (but I'd have to get paid after 20 years)! LOL!