Rank your best Quarterbacks in NFL history

[LeRoy]

Catagory C Dont forget Otto Graham

[flarendep1]

Ok my unbiased picks:

For all categories except most overrated:


Tom Brady
Tom Brady
Tom Brady










Signed: Wayne

[wayne1218]

Category A: Best running QB all time

1) Tom Brady
2) Steve Grogan
3) Drew Bledsoe




Category B: Most accurate passer all time

1) Tom Brady
2) Tony Eason
3) Matt Cassell


Category C: Toughest QB all time

1) Tom Brady
2) Doug Flutie
3) Drew Bledsoe


Category D: Strongest Arm of all time

1) Tom Brady
2) Drew Bledsoe
3) Jim Plunkett


Category E: Best inside of two minutes

1) Tom Brady
2) Tom Brady
3) Tom Brady

Category F: Most Underated QB of all time

1) Tom Brady
2) Matt Cassell
3) Steve Grogan

Category G: Most Overrated QB of all time

1) Tony Romo
2) Dan Marino
3) Brett Favre

[packer34]

Ok my unbiased picks:

For all categories except most overrated:


Tom Brady
Tom Brady
Tom Brady







Signed: Wayne

Don't you just love people answer you questions seriously!

[BettorsChat]

Site with a write-up of their top 10 qb's of all time.

Cold, Hard Football Facts.com: The definitive list: Top 10 NFL quarterbacks

[wayne1218]

Site with a write-up of their top 10 qb's of all time.

Cold, Hard Football Facts.com: The definitive list: Top 10 NFL quarterbacks

I agree with leaving Marino OFF that list!!!

[BettorsChat]

Steve Wyche ranks his all-time best QBs. Find out who beat out Tom Brady and Joe Montana.

10. Troy Aikman
9. Warren Moon
8. Y.A. Tittle
7. John Elway (Most sacked QB ever)
6. Dan Marino
5. Brett Favre
4. Tom Brady
3. Peyton Manning
2. Joe Montana
1. Johnny Unitas

Steve Wyche ranks his all-time best QBs. Find out who beat out Tom Brady and Joe Montana.

[BettorsChat]

I agree with leaving Marino OFF that list!!!

Is Brady best ever? Not yet, but time is on his side

Is Brady best ever? Not yet, but time is on his side - NFL - ESPN

[packer34]

Site with a write-up of their top 10 qb's of all time.

Cold, Hard Football Facts.com: The definitive list: Top 10 NFL quarterbacks

That's funny I was talking to my friends dad (from Dallas) the other day about football and who he thought was the best QB of all time. I was saying Montana, and he said Bart Starr without hesitating.

[flarendep1]

Steve Wyche ranks his all-time best QBs. Find out who beat out Tom Brady and Joe Montana.

10. Troy Aikman
9. Warren Moon
8. Y.A. Tittle
7. John Elway (Most sacked QB ever)
6. Dan Marino
5. Brett Favre
4. Tom Brady
3. Peyton Manning
2. Joe Montana
1. Johnny Unitas

Steve Wyche ranks his all-time best QBs. Find out who beat out Tom Brady and Joe Montana.

Steve Young has the all time career highest passer rating, I would have him ahead of Aikman for sure.

[wayne1218]

Steve Young has the all time career highest passer rating, I would have him ahead of Aikman for sure.

Definately put Young IN and take Marino OUT!

[frankb03]

Definately put Young IN and take Marino OUT!

Young is top 5 for me.

[wayne1218]

Young is top 5 for me.

Do you remember Young in the USFL?

Was it the LA Express he played for? I forget now but i remember him playing!

[flarendep1]

Check out the run against the Vikings to win the game in the final seconds. Best individual run by a QB ever IMO!


YouTube - Steve Young career highlights.

[wayne1218]

Steve Young was AMAZING with his arm and his legs!!!