Rank your best Quarterbacks in NFL history

[flarendep1]

Since the Favre thread has so much interest, I thought it might be interesting to hear opinions in a different format.

Make your picks on talent of the QB not the team they played on.



Rank your top 3 by category:

?Here are mine:



Category A: Best running QB all time

1) Steve Young
2) Randall Cunningham
3) Fran Tarkenton

* Michael Vick maybe but he was not a real QB


Category B: Most accurate passer all time

1) John Unitias
2) Steve Young
3) Kurt Warner


Category C: Toughest QB all time

1) Brett Favre
2) Steve McNair
3) Jim Kelly


Category D: Strongest Arm of all time

1) Brett Favre
2) John Elway
3) Terry Bradshaw


Category E: Best inside of two minutes

1) Joe Montana
2) Tom Brady
3) John Elway

Category F: Most Underated QB of all time

1) Phil Simms
2) Warren Moon
3) Ken Anderson

Category G: Most Overrated QB of all time

1) Troy Aikman
2) Terry Bradshaw
3) Joe Namath




Add another category if you want

[MarkLemke]

category h: shittiest quarterbacks of all time
1. ryan leaf
2. jemarcus russell
3. ryan leaf

[mavskidd02]

Awesome thread Flare. I will get back when me and Wayne get thru arguing with each other.

Expect me back in about a month or two.

[frankb03]

Cat C:

Phil Simms was as tough as they come.

[musclemann]

Since the Favre thread has so much interest, I thought it might be interesting to hear opinions in a different format.

Make your picks on talent of the QB not the team they played on.



Rank your top 3 by category:

?Here are mine:



Category A: Best running QB all time

1) Steve Young
2) Randall Cunningham
3) Fran Tarkenton

* Michael Vick maybe but he was not a real QB


Category B: Most accurate passer all time

1) John Unitias
2) Steve Young
3) Kurt Warner


Category C: Toughest QB all time

1) Brett Favre
2) Steve McNair
3) Jim Kelly


Category D: Strongest Arm of all time

1) Brett Favre
2) John Elway
3) Terry Bradshaw


Category E: Best inside of two minutes

1) Joe Montana
2) Tom Brady
3) John Elway

Category F: Most Underated QB of all time

1) Phil Simms
2) Warren Moon
3) Ken Anderson

Category G: Most Overrated QB of all time

1) Troy Aikman
2) Terry Bradshaw
3) Joe Namath




Add another category if you want

This is your best post of all time flare. Good call here

[flarendep1]

Awesome thread Flare. I will get back when me and Wayne get thru arguing with each other.

Expect me back in about a month or two.

[flarendep1]

This is your best post of all time flare. Good call here

Thanks, taking a politics break for now


Join in man, give me your list

[dss_pansat]

You maybe miss Dan Marino :-)

[ravenmaniac]

I think it is really difficult to compare eras. With the rule changes that have gone into effect in the last 10 years, which has predominantly benefitted the passing game, who knows what numbers a QB like John Unitas could put up today if he was playing. One catagory you left out. Considering all the factors you just mentioned these are my top 3 all around QBs

1. Joe Montana
2. John Unitas
3. Roger Staubach

[jcindaville]

category h: shittiest quarterbacks of all time
1. ryan leaf
2. jemarcus russell
3. ryan leaf

[frankb03]

Awesome thread Flare. I will get back when me and Wayne get thru arguing with each other.

Expect me back in about a month or two.

OMG!!! LMAO @ this post.

[Helmetsniffer]

category h: shittiest quarterbacks of all time
1. ryan leaf
2. jemarcus russell
3. ryan leaf

Kordell Stewart

[MrReporter]

JOE MONTANA

Simply the best all time.

[packer34]

category h: Shittiest quarterbacks of all time
1. Ryan leaf
2. Jemarcus russell
3. Ryan leaf

lol

[packer34]

Where's Peyton Manning in any of these catagories, his stats should go up after this year. Easiest schedule for a team I've ever seen! Unbelievable!