Advice needed please....

[xstac2169]

OK Guys in a fantasy football league and having a problem with who to start at QB tomorrow.

Vince Young
Kurt Warner

Now, you get points based on only the following categories:
Pa2P - Passing Two-point Conversion 2 points
PaTD - Passing TD 6 points
Plus 3 points for a PaTD of 10 to 39 Yds
Plus 6 points for a PaTD of 40+ Yds

PaYd - Passing Yards Plus a 10 point bonus @ 300+ PaYd

Special Scoring for Quarterbacks

Ru2P - Rushing Two-point Conversion 4 points
RuTD - Rushing TD 12 points
Plus 6 points for a RuTD of 10 to 39 Yds
Plus 12 points for a RuTD of 40+ Yds

RuYd - Rushing Yards Plus a 10 point bonus @ 100+ RuYd



Who do you start? I cant see either guy throwing for 300+ yards. With Mathis out for Jacksonville, I feel like Young might be the better start. I can see him throwing for 1 and running 1 in. Any advice as to who to start would be much appreciated.

[griffey_mojo]

I would NEVER start VY over Warner...JMO

[wayne1218]

I would NEVER start VY over Warner...JMO

Ditto. You shouldn't need advice for this one!!!

[uconnplayer]

this is a stupid thread guy. If you can't make this descion on your own you should not be playing fantasy football. Get a clue guy

[griffey_mojo]

this is a stupid thread guy. If you can't make this descion on your own you should not be playing fantasy football. Get a clue guy

Uncalled for GUY!!!

[xstac2169]

OK its the simple fact that it is not an ordinary league and Warner has not thrown more than 2tds in any game this year so far. If Young runs one in then he would score as many points, 12, as Warner would. That is the predicament I am running into. Can Young throw 1 and run 1 in this week against jacksonville? If he did he would score more points for me than Warner would. So as you can see based on the point system it is not the easiest call in the world.

I understand that normally Warner would never be benched in favor of Young. However, Jacksonville is starting a rookie CB and third string CB this week in Tenn where they are desperate for a win. Last time Young came in for Tenn he was amazing in a similar situation.

If you actually read the scoring system and thought it out just a tad bit, you would see that this is not the easiest call.

[wayne1218]

I looked at the system and i still can't start Young. No way. He has looked awful and Warner could throw 3 or 4 TD's

[griffey_mojo]

I'm just anti-VY....GL in your decision!

can easily see VY throwing a couple picks and a loss fumble too...to me it looks like the Titans have given up on their coach...